Comparison of Three Modalities to Assess Clinical Competence of Medical Students

Summary

This study, focusing on the management of pediatric asthma exacerbations, assesses the clinical skills of medical students using three different evaluation tools: (i) the simulation game "Effic'Asthme" developed to train individuals on the management of pediatric asthma exacerbations; (ii) a multiple choice questionnaire (MCQ) on the same subject developed for the purpose of the study and (iii) high fidelity (HF)-simulation, considered as the gold-standard for its enhanced realism.

Its objective is to determine which of the simulation game or the MCQ reflects the best the clinical competence of medical students evaluated on a HF simulator.

Conditions

• Educational Problems

Interventions

OTHER

High-fidelity simulation

The first evaluation modality studied is high fidelity (HF) simulation. In our study, this modality is considered to be the gold-standard assessment method of clinical assessment, because HF simulation corresponds to the modality which reflects the best clinical competence in hospital settings. The HF pediatric manikin used (SimBaby), is able to reproduce all the signs of an asthma exacerbation (coughing, wheezing, tachypnea, chest indrawing, seesaw respiration, cyanosis). In the simulation room, participants can use the same items that those present in the simulation game (a glass of water, paracetamol, short acting beta-agonist, controller treatment (Fluticasone), an asthma spacer with a facial mask, saline nose drops to perform nasal irrigation, oral steroids in tablets (prednisone), and a phone).

OTHER

Simulation game

EfficAsthme is a simulation game used on a tablet computer. This simulation game was developed to train parents on the management of asthma exacerbations of their children. For the purpose of the study, EfficAsthme is diverted from its original use to assess students' clinical skills. The training scenario "A polluted atmosphere" is used in this study. Participants need to observe the signs presented by the child, and to determine the severity of the asthma exacerbation. From a menu on the right of the screen, the participant can choose several actions, especially to provide the short acting beta-agonist.

OTHER

Multiple choice questionnaire

The third evaluation modality corresponds to a multiple choice questionnaire (MCQ) including 15 questions. As for HF-simulation and the simulation game, the MCQ starts with the same briefing and continues with 15 questions regarding the management of a moderate asthma exacerbation.

Sponsors & Collaborators

• Ilumens

  lead OTHER

Principal Investigators

• David Drummond, MD, PhD · Université Paris Descartes

Study Design

Purpose

OTHER

Masking

NONE

Model

SEQUENTIAL

Eligibility

Min Age

18 Years

Sex

ALL

Healthy Volunteers

Yes

Timeline & Regulatory

Start

2019-03-20

Primary Completion

2019-07-06

Completion

2019-07-06

Countries

• France

Study Locations