Comparison of the Cognitive, Dual-task and Physical Effects of 6 Programs With Older Adults

Summary

While the association of physical and/or motor and/or cognitive components with training can generate synergistic effects and thus create an efficient cognitive enrichment program, very few studies have focused on finding an optimal combined program for older adults. According to the model of Herold and his colleagues, there are two modalities of simultaneous combined training: Thinking While Moving (TwM), when the additional cognitive task is not linked to the motor task, and Moving While Thinking (MwT), when the cognitive task is integrated into the motor task. They assume the latter approach is the most promising for improving cognitive reserve. Nevertheless, to the investigators' knowledge, only one study has compared these two modalities in older adults and none has broadened the question by comparing several MwT trainings.

The goal of this interventional study will be to compare the cognitive, dual-task, and physical effects of 6 physical and/or cognitive programs in healthy but inactive older adults. The main questions it will aims to answer are:

* Will the Moving While Thinking and Thinking While Moving programs have the same effects?
* If they have different effects, which will be the best way to improve cognitive, dual-task, and physical functions? The study is being set up between 2023 and 2025 to compare the cognitive, dual- ask and physical effects of 6 programs (3 months, 2 sessions of 1 hour per week). Three experimental MwT programs will be studied: Immersive and interactive wall exergames (I2WE), Complex Cognitive and Motor Activities (2CMA), and exergames with Switch (EXER). They will be compared to an experimental TwM program of stationary bike simultaneous to the Switch (Video games + bike) and 2 control programs: inactive video games (VG) and stationary bike (BIKE). A control group (CON) will be also created.

Cognitive, dual-task, and physical pre-tests (before the program), post-tests (after the program), and retention tests (3 months after the end of the program) will be realized to evaluate the effects of the programs.

Conditions

• Physical Fitness
• Cognitive Function

Interventions

OTHER

Immersive and Interactive Wall Exergames

This intervention will be performed using the Neo One device. It was chosen because of the variety and quality of the games offered which are accessible to older people. The target intensity of core workout will be moderate. Five to 7 five-minutes games will be selected from 19 games. A variety of materials will be used (e.g., basketball, rugby, handball ball, balloon, chair, hoop, rhythm ladder, tennis racket). The games will be made more complex by selecting difficulty settings (easy, normal, hard) and by adding extra exercises to add cooperative and/or oppositional situations to the games where they are not initially implemented and to increase the physical and/or motor complexity. Interventions will last 12 weeks, with 2 sessions of 1-h per week (24 h in total). The sessions will consist in 10 minutes of warmup, 45 minutes of the main session using the Neo One device and 5 minutes of cooldown with full body stretching exercises, in groups of 4 participants.

OTHER

Complex Cognitive and Motor Activities program

The intervention will last 12 weeks, with 2 sessions of 1-h per week (24 h in total). The sessions will consist in 10 minutes of warmup, 45 minutes of the main sessions involving cooperation and opposition exercises inspired by team sports (basketball, volleyball, rugby) and individual sports (boxing, weight training), and 5 minutes of cooldown with full body stretching exercises, in groups of 6 participants. The target intensity of body workout will be moderate. The first part will be focused on endurance and the second on muscle strengthening and coordination work in the form of circuit training. A variety of equipment will be used (e.g., tennis balls, basketballs, volleyballs, rugby balls, balloons, elastics, chairs, blocks). The number of partners and/or opponents will be changed regularly.

OTHER

exergames program

The intervention will last 12 weeks, with 2 sessions of 1-h per week (24 h in total). The sessions will be performed using the Nintendo Switch device, physically active (standing). The sessions will consist in 10 minutes of warmup, 45 minutes of the main session using the Nintendo Switch device and 5 minutes of cooldown with full body stretching exercises, in groups of 4 participants. The games (Fitness Boxing 2, Switch Sport, Just Dance 2020, 2021, 2023, Let's Get Fit, Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games Tokyo 2020, Instant Sport, Ring Fit, Zumba Burn It Up!) will be carried out in the form of circuit training, in pairs or groups of 4. The games will be made more complex by selecting difficulty settings (easy, normal, hard) and by adding extra exercises to add cooperative and/or oppositional situations to the games where they are not initially implemented and to increase the physical and/or motor complexity.

OTHER

video games program

The intervention will last 12 weeks, with 2 sessions of 1-h per week (24 h in total). The sessions will be performed using the Nintendo Switch device, while being inactive (sitting). The sessions will consist in one-hour single and multi-players games, using the Nintendo Switch device, in groups of 6 participants.

OTHER

Bike

The intervention will last 12 weeks, with 2 sessions of 1-h per week (24 h in total). In this active comparator intervention, the sessions will consist in 10 minutes of warmup, 45 minutes of the main sessions involving riding a stationary bike at about 50% of Heart Rate Reserve, and 5 minutes of cooldown with full body stretching exercises, in groups of 6 participants.

OTHER

Video games + bike

The intervention will last 12 weeks, with 2 sessions of 1-h per week (24 h in total). In this experimental arm, the sessions will consist in 10 minutes of warmup, 45 minutes of the main sessions involving riding a stationary bike (like BIKE program at about 50% of Heart Rate Reserve) and at the same time playing on a Nintendo Switch (like VG program), and 5 minutes of cooldown with full body stretching exercises, in groups of 6 participants.

Sponsors & Collaborators

• Université Paris Cité

  collaborator OTHER

• Alexandra Perrot

  lead OTHER

Principal Investigators

• Alexandra Perrot · Université Paris-Saclay

• Pauline Maillot · Université Paris Cité

Study Design

Allocation

NON_RANDOMIZED

Purpose

PREVENTION

Masking

SINGLE

Model

PARALLEL

Eligibility

Min Age

60 Years

Sex

ALL

Healthy Volunteers

Yes

Timeline & Regulatory

Start

2023-02-13

Primary Completion

2024-12-15

Completion

2025-05-15

Countries

• France

Study Locations