Trial Outcomes & Findings for Organic Diet Intervention in Primary School Children (NCT NCT02998203)

NCT ID: NCT02998203

Last Updated: 2023-09-07

Results Overview

Percent change in pesticide metabolite 3-phenoxybenzoic acid (3-PBA) levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last sample of organic treatment period. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Recruitment status

COMPLETED

Study phase

NA

Target enrollment

191 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

Last sample of the conventional period and the last sample of organic period, up to 40 days for each period

Results posted on

2023-09-07

Participant Flow

Unit of analysis: Schools

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
Group 1 (Organic Period First, Then Conventional Period)
Schools in Group 1 began first with the organic period and continued with the conventional period. The organic period was organized in two 20-day cycles with differences in the menu to allow for greater variety in the meals, so that the participants' compliance to the organic treatment would be enhanced. During the organic period, participants were asked to strictly follow the two 20-day organic dietary menus provided to them for a total of 40 days. During the conventional period, participants were asked to maintain their usual dietary habits and choices (\>80% conventional diet) for a total of maximum 40 days.
Group 2 (Conventional Period First, Then Organic Period)
Schools in Group 2 began first with the conventional period and then switched to the organic period. During the conventional period, participants were asked to maintain their usual dietary habits and choices (\>80% conventional diet) for a total of maximum 40 days. The organic period was organized in two 20-day cycles with differences in the menu to allow for greater variety in the meals, so that the participants' compliance to the organic treatment would be enhanced. During the organic period, participants were asked to strictly follow the two 20-day organic dietary menus provided to them for a total of 40 days.
First Period (40 Days)
STARTED
67 3
124 3
First Period (40 Days)
COMPLETED
43 3
124 3
First Period (40 Days)
NOT COMPLETED
24 0
0 0
Second Period (40 Days)
STARTED
43 3
124 3
Second Period (40 Days)
COMPLETED
43 3
106 3
Second Period (40 Days)
NOT COMPLETED
0 0
18 0

Reasons for withdrawal

Reasons for withdrawal
Measure
Group 1 (Organic Period First, Then Conventional Period)
Schools in Group 1 began first with the organic period and continued with the conventional period. The organic period was organized in two 20-day cycles with differences in the menu to allow for greater variety in the meals, so that the participants' compliance to the organic treatment would be enhanced. During the organic period, participants were asked to strictly follow the two 20-day organic dietary menus provided to them for a total of 40 days. During the conventional period, participants were asked to maintain their usual dietary habits and choices (\>80% conventional diet) for a total of maximum 40 days.
Group 2 (Conventional Period First, Then Organic Period)
Schools in Group 2 began first with the conventional period and then switched to the organic period. During the conventional period, participants were asked to maintain their usual dietary habits and choices (\>80% conventional diet) for a total of maximum 40 days. The organic period was organized in two 20-day cycles with differences in the menu to allow for greater variety in the meals, so that the participants' compliance to the organic treatment would be enhanced. During the organic period, participants were asked to strictly follow the two 20-day organic dietary menus provided to them for a total of 40 days.
First Period (40 Days)
Withdrawal by Subject
24
0
Second Period (40 Days)
Withdrawal by Subject
0
18

Baseline Characteristics

Race and Ethnicity were not collected from any participant.

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
Group 1
n=43 Participants
Schools in Group 1 began first with the organic period and continued with the conventional period. The organic period was organized in two 20-day cycles with differences in the menu to allow for greater variety in the meals, so that the participants' compliance to the organic treatment would be enhanced. During the organic period, participants were asked to strictly follow the two 20-day organic dietary menus provided to them for a total of 40 days. During the conventional period, participants were asked to maintain their usual dietary habits and choices (\>80% conventional diet) for a total of maximum 40 days.
Group 2
n=106 Participants
Schools in Group 2 began first with the conventional period and then switched to the organic period. During the conventional period, participants were asked to maintain their usual dietary habits and choices (\>80% conventional diet) for a total of maximum 40 days. The organic period was organized in two 20-day cycles with differences in the menu to allow for greater variety in the meals, so that the participants' compliance to the organic treatment would be enhanced. During the organic period, participants were asked to strictly follow the two 20-day organic dietary menus provided to them for a total of 40 days.
Total
n=149 Participants
Total of all reporting groups
Age, Continuous
11.03 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.53 • n=43 Participants
11.21 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.61 • n=106 Participants
11.16 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.59 • n=149 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
14 Participants
n=43 Participants
59 Participants
n=106 Participants
73 Participants
n=149 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
29 Participants
n=43 Participants
47 Participants
n=106 Participants
76 Participants
n=149 Participants
Race and Ethnicity Not Collected
0 Participants
Race and Ethnicity were not collected from any participant.

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: Last sample of the conventional period and the last sample of organic period, up to 40 days for each period

Population: The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels.

Percent change in pesticide metabolite 3-phenoxybenzoic acid (3-PBA) levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last sample of organic treatment period. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Change in Pesticide Metabolite 3-phenoxybenzoic Acid (3-PBA) Levels in Urine Between Organic and Conventional Periods*
11.4 % change
Interval 5.7 to 17.2

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

Overall difference in median 3-PBA levels between the conventional and organic periods. The overall differences in the medians of biomarkers between the conventional and the organic phase were assessed with the non-parametric Wilcoxon rank sum test on the creatinine-adjusted concentrations pooling all conventional samples (including the baseline) and the organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
n=6 schools
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Overall Difference in Median 3-PBA Levels in Urine Between the Conventional and Organic Periods*
2088 ng/g creatinine
Interval 689.0 to 5273.0
576 ng/g creatinine
Interval 164.0 to 1681.0

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

A linear mixed-effect regression model was fitted for 3-PBA (log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted). The model accounted for the duration and the effect of treatment. It included student-level (repeated measures within person) and school-level (multiple students clustered within each school) random intercepts with an unstructured covariance matrix. Continuous variables, other than time (days of treatment), were centered at the population means. The model included fixed effects for treatment condition (organic or conventional) and time (days of treatment), where time = 0 was used for the start of the treatment. The model was adjusted for the baseline value (first urine sample for all children) of the outcome to account for the background participant levels. An interaction term for time and treatment was considered and subsequently dropped if it did not meet the threshold of p-value\<0. 05.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Effect of Organic Treatment in 3-PBA Levels in Urine, Taking in Account the Repeated Measures and Duration of Organic Period
-1.214 ng/g creatinine (log-transformed)
Interval -1.44 to -0.987

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

Overall difference in median 6-CN levels between the conventional and organic periods. The overall differences in the medians of biomarkers between the conventional and the organic phase were assessed with the non-parametric Wilcoxon rank sum test on the creatinine-adjusted concentrations pooling all conventional samples (including the baseline) and the organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
n=6 schools
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Overall Difference in Median 6-chloronicotininc Acid (6-CN) Levels in Urine Between the Conventional and Organic Periods*
26 ng/g creatinine
Interval 6.0 to 180.0
20 ng/g creatinine
Interval 5.0 to 79.0

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

A logistic model was fitted for 6-CN (binary variable; above and below LOD) due to the high number of values below LOD. The model accounted for the duration and the effect of treatment. It included student-level (repeated measures within person) and school-level (multiple students clustered within each school) random intercepts with an unstructured covariance matrix. Continuous variables, other than time (days of treatment), were centered at the population means. The model included fixed effects for treatment condition (organic or conventional) and time (days of treatment), where time = 0 was used for the start of the treatment. The model was adjusted for the baseline value (first urine sample for all children) of the outcome to account for the background participant levels. An interaction term for time and treatment was considered and subsequently dropped if it did not meet the threshold of p-value\<0. 05.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Effect of Organic Treatment in 6-CN Levels in Urine, Taking in Account the Repeated Measures and Duration of Organic Period - Odds Ratio Calculated Based on the Fit of a Logistic Mixed-effect Model
0.651 Odds Ratio
Interval 0.463 to 0.917

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Last sample of the conventional period and the last sample of organic period, up to 40 days for each period

Population: The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels.

Percent change in oxidative stress/inflammation biomarker 8-OHdG levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last sample of organic treatment period. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Change in Oxidative Stress/Inflammation Biomarker 8-OHdG Levels in Urine Between Organic and Conventional Periods*
1.7 % change
Interval -0.7 to 4.0

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

Overall difference in median 8-OHdG levels between the conventional and organic periods. The overall differences in the medians of biomarkers between the conventional and the organic phase were assessed with the non-parametric Wilcoxon rank sum test on the creatinine-adjusted concentrations pooling all conventional samples (including the baseline) and the organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
n=6 schools
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Overall Difference in Median 8-OHdG Levels in Urine Between the Conventional and Organic Periods*
323 ug/g creatinine
Interval 222.0 to 471.0
296 ug/g creatinine
Interval 202.0 to 447.0

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

A linear mixed-effect regression model was fitted for 8-OHdG (log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted). The model accounted for the duration and the effect of treatment. It included student-level (repeated measures within person) and school-level (multiple students clustered within each school) random intercepts with an unstructured covariance matrix. Continuous variables, other than time (days of treatment), were centered at the population means. The model included fixed effects for treatment condition (organic or conventional) and time (days of treatment), where time = 0 was used for the start of the treatment. The model was adjusted for the baseline value (first urine sample for all children) of the outcome to account for the background participant levels. An interaction term for time and treatment was considered and subsequently dropped if it did not meet the threshold of p-value\<0. 05.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Effect of Organic Treatment in 8-OHdG Levels in Urine, Taking in Account the Repeated Measures and Duration of Organic Period
-0.119 ug/g creatinine (log-transformed)
Interval -0.213 to -0.024

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Last sample of the conventional period and the last sample of organic period, up to 40 days for each period

Population: The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels.

Percent change in oxidative stress/inflammation biomarker 8-iso-PGF2a levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last sample of organic treatment period. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Change in Oxidative Stress/Inflammation Biomarker 8-iso-PGF2a Levels in Urine Between Organic and Conventional Periods*
1.6 % change
Interval 0.2 to 2.9

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

Overall difference in median 8-iso-PGF2a levels between the conventional and organic periods. The overall differences in the medians of biomarkers between the conventional and the organic phase were assessed with the non-parametric Wilcoxon rank sum test on the creatinine-adjusted concentrations pooling all conventional samples (including the baseline) and the organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
n=6 schools
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Overall Difference in Median 8-iso-PGF2a Levels in Urine Between the Conventional and Organic Periods*
2964 ug/g creatinine
Interval 2112.0 to 3871.0
3028 ug/g creatinine
Interval 2300.0 to 3955.0

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

A linear mixed-effect regression model was fitted for 8-iso-PGF2a (log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted). The model accounted for the duration and the effect of treatment. It included student-level (repeated measures within person) and school-level (multiple students clustered within each school) random intercepts with an unstructured covariance matrix. Continuous variables, other than time (days of treatment), were centered at the population means. The model included fixed effects for treatment condition (organic or conventional) and time (days of treatment), where time = 0 was used for the start of the treatment. The model was adjusted for the baseline value (first urine sample for all children) of the outcome to account for the background participant levels. An interaction term for time and treatment was considered and subsequently dropped if it did not meet the threshold of p-value\<0. 05.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Effect of Organic Treatment in 8-iso-PGF2a Levels in Urine, Taking in Account the Repeated Measures and Duration of Organic Period
0.408 ug/g creatinine (log-transformed)
Interval 0.232 to 0.584

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Last sample of the conventional period and the last sample of organic period, up to 40 days for each period

Population: The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels.

Percent change in oxidative stress/inflammation biomarker MDA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last sample of organic treatment period. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Change in Oxidative Stress/Inflammation Biomarker MDA Levels in Urine Between Organic and Conventional Periods*
0.1 % change
Interval -1.1 to 1.2

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

Overall difference in median MDA levels between the conventional and organic periods. The overall differences in the medians of biomarkers between the conventional and the organic phase were assessed with the non-parametric Wilcoxon rank sum test on the creatinine-adjusted concentrations pooling all conventional samples (including the baseline) and the organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment. \*Note: This test does not take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration. The results of the linear-mixed effect models are the ones considered (reported in a section below) as they take into account the repeated measures for each participant and the organic treatment duration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
n=6 schools
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Overall Difference in Median MDA Levels in Urine Between the Conventional and Organic Periods*
858 umol/g creatinine
Interval 691.0 to 1016.0
846 umol/g creatinine
Interval 725.0 to 1029.0

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 baseline sample, 2 samples in the conventional period (typical conventional diet) and 3 samples in the organic period, up to 40 days for each Period

Population: Three schools were randomly allocated to Group 1 (67 children) and the other three to Group 2 (124 children). In total, 24 children from Group 1 and 18 children from Group 2 who withdrew from the study 1-11 days after the beginning of the organic period and did not provide an organic period urine sample, were excluded from the data analysis.

A linear mixed-effect regression model was fitted for MDA (log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted). The model accounted for the duration and the effect of treatment. It included student-level (repeated measures within person) and school-level (multiple students clustered within each school) random intercepts with an unstructured covariance matrix. Continuous variables, other than time (days of treatment), were centered at the population means. The model included fixed effects for treatment condition (organic or conventional) and time (days of treatment), where time = 0 was used for the start of the treatment. The model was adjusted for the baseline value (first urine sample for all children) of the outcome to account for the background participant levels. An interaction term for time and treatment was considered and subsequently dropped if it did not meet the threshold of p-value\<0. 05.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
% Change in 3-PBA Between Last Sample of Conventional Period and Last Sample of Organic Period
n=6 schools
Percent change in 3-PBA levels between the last sample of the conventional treatment period (before the start of the organic treatment) and the last urine sample of organic treatment period. The percent change was estimated only for the participants who completed the full course of the organic treatment, using the log-transformed, creatinine-adjusted biomarker levels. A one-sample t-test was used to assess whether the percent change was different than zero.
Median 3-PBA Levels in the Organic Period
Median 3-PBA levels (creatinine-adjusted) in the organic period by pooling all organic samples for all participants, regardless of the duration for which they followed the organic treatment.
Effect of Organic Treatment in MDA Levels in Urine, Taking in Account the Repeated Measures and Duration of Organic Period
0.189 umol/g creatinine (log-transformed)
Interval 0.083 to 0.295

Adverse Events

Group 1

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Group 2

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Other adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Additional Information

Dr. Konstantinos C. Makris

Cyprus University of Technology

Phone: 00357-25-002398

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee
  • Publication restrictions are in place