Trial Outcomes & Findings for Promoting Clinical Guidelines for Opioid Prescribing (NCT NCT04044521)

NCT ID: NCT04044521

Last Updated: 2024-06-17

Results Overview

The average morphine milligram equivalent will be reported at the clinic level. Patients included in this outcome are those who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in the last 3 consecutive months. For a comparison of opioids doses, a conversion factors were developed to equate the many different opioids into one standard value. This standard value is based on morphine and its potency, referred to as morphine milligram equivalents (MME) or morphine equivalent doses (MED).

Recruitment status

COMPLETED

Study phase

NA

Target enrollment

268 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

up to 30 months

Results posted on

2024-06-17

Participant Flow

The study team focused outreach efforts toward clinics to build awareness about this study. An email was sent to clinic medical directors of the health system to instruct them how to opt-out if they wish to decline participation in the study and future contact from the study team. The study team enrolled 'providers' as participants and focused on clinic-level data.

Unit of analysis: Clinics

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
Academic Detailing Only
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Overall Study
STARTED
60 8
65 8
66 8
77 8
Overall Study
COMPLETED
60 8
65 8
66 8
77 8
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0

Reasons for withdrawal

Withdrawal data not reported

Baseline Characteristics

unknown and not applicable

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
Academic Detailing Only
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Total
n=32 Clinics
Total of all reporting groups
Sex: Female, Male
Female
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
Sex: Female, Male
Male
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
0 Participants
unknown and not applicable
Race and Ethnicity Not Collected
0 Participants
Race and Ethnicity were not collected from any participant.
Average MME per day for most recent 3 months
44.9938 morphine milligram equivalents per day
STANDARD_DEVIATION 22.4591 • n=8 Clinics
39.6526 morphine milligram equivalents per day
STANDARD_DEVIATION 17.2418 • n=8 Clinics
36.6330 morphine milligram equivalents per day
STANDARD_DEVIATION 15.7656 • n=8 Clinics
48.9800 morphine milligram equivalents per day
STANDARD_DEVIATION 20.1475 • n=8 Clinics
43.3 morphine milligram equivalents per day
STANDARD_DEVIATION 19.7 • n=32 Clinics
Percent of patients with average MME greater than or equal to 90 mg/day
0.1142 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1175 • n=8 Clinics
0.1033 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1014 • n=8 Clinics
0.0741 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.0954 • n=8 Clinics
0.1326 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1080 • n=8 Clinics
0.109 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.109 • n=32 Clinics
Percent of patients with co-prescribed Benzodiazepine in the last quarter
0.1600 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.0920 • n=8 Clinics
0.1123 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.0817 • n=8 Clinics
0.1351 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1097 • n=8 Clinics
0.1178 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1095 • n=8 Clinics
0.132 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1 • n=32 Clinics
Percent of patients with urine drug screen in last 12 months
0.3302 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.2577 • n=8 Clinics
0.2555 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.2343 • n=8 Clinics
0.2628 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.2089 • n=8 Clinics
0.3276 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.2087 • n=8 Clinics
0.298 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.234 • n=32 Clinics
Percent of patients with treatment in last 12 months
0.3302 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1946 • n=8 Clinics
0.1316 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.2047 • n=8 Clinics
0.1982 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1593 • n=8 Clinics
0.1341 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1711 • n=8 Clinics
0.16 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.188 • n=32 Clinics
Percent of patients with PHQ-8/9 depression screen in last 12 months
0.2791 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1936 • n=8 Clinics
0.2464 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1584 • n=8 Clinics
0.2673 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.2101 • n=8 Clinics
0.2346 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1563 • n=8 Clinics
0.258 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.18 • n=32 Clinics
Percent of patients with PEG-3 pain screen in last 12 months
0.1234 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.2070 • n=8 Clinics
0.0291 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.0596 • n=8 Clinics
0.0073 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.0157 • n=8 Clinics
0.0919 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.1602 • n=8 Clinics
0.069 percent of patients
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.151 • n=32 Clinics

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

Population: Outcome measure provides clinic-level data. Participants enrolled are providers.

The average morphine milligram equivalent will be reported at the clinic level. Patients included in this outcome are those who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in the last 3 consecutive months. For a comparison of opioids doses, a conversion factors were developed to equate the many different opioids into one standard value. This standard value is based on morphine and its potency, referred to as morphine milligram equivalents (MME) or morphine equivalent doses (MED).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Average Morphine Milligram Equivalent (MME) Per Day of Chronic Opioid Prescriptions of Clinics
320.69 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 11.80
372.33 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 20.04
275.55 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 16.78
455.62 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 19.59

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

Population: Outcome measure provides prescriber-level data. Participants enrolled are providers.

The average morphine milligram equivalent will be reported at the prescriber level. Patients included in this outcome are those who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in the last 3 consecutive months.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=65 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=60 Participants
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=66 Participants
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=77 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Average Morphine Milligram Equivalent of Chronic Opioid Prescriptions of Prescribers
39.65 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 17.24
45.00 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 22.46
36.63 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 15.77
48.98 average MME/day
Standard Deviation 20.15

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of eligible clinics that participated in the study.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=7 Clinics
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Number of Eligible Clinics That Participated
8 Clinics
7 Clinics
8 Clinics
8 Clinics

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of eligible clinicians who participated in the study

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=8 clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=7 clinics
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=8 clinics
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=8 clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Number of Clinicians Who Participated in the Study
65 participants
60 participants
66 participants
77 participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The total number of patients seen at clinics will be used to assess clinic size.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=8 clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=7 clinics
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=8 clinics
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=8 clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Number of Patients at Clinics
2486 patients
2427 patients
2044 patients
2021 patients

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of clinicians who attended the meeting for practice facilitation, physician peer consulting, and follow-up meetings.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=65 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=60 Participants
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=66 Participants
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=77 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Number of Clinicians Who Attended the Intervention Meetings
6.118461538 average participants
Standard Deviation 11.36059744
6.741935484 average participants
Standard Deviation 18.26451613
6.228070175 average participants
Standard Deviation 22.34556254
6.15 average participants
Standard Deviation 28.32195122

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The average time (in hours) of intervention that clinics received.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=7 Clinics
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Average Hours of Intervention Received Per Clinic
12.5 hours
Standard Deviation 17.5
4.571428571 hours
Standard Deviation 1.673469388
14.875 hours
Standard Deviation 31.609375
6.125 hours
Standard Deviation 9.609375

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The average time (in hours) of intervention that prescribers received. The average time the prescriber received the intervention (in hours) is the same amount of time as the average intervention time that each clinic receives, because our intervention is at the clinic level.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=65 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=60 Participants
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=66 Participants
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=77 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Average Hours of Intervention Received Per Prescriber
12.5 hours
Standard Deviation 17.5
4.571428571 hours
Standard Deviation 1.673469388
14.875 hours
Standard Deviation 31.609375
6.125 hours
Standard Deviation 9.609375

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The estimated cost of each implementation sequence and combination in US dollars. The result is derived from the number of intervention hours calculated for each arm, multiplied by the average salary of the staff who gave the intervention (e.g., the facilitators, providers, and IT coordinator), referenced from publicly reported data (Medscape Family Medicine Physician Compensation Report).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=65 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=60 Participants
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=66 Participants
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=77 Participants
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Estimated Cost of Each Study Arm in US Dollars
7933.2 dollars
2307.84 dollars
9015 dollars
4399.32 dollars

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

A assessment tool is under development to capture the quality improvement experience level of clinics.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

A list and count of the components of the participating health systems' opioid prescribing policy.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

A list and count of adaptations that were made to the intervention during the intervention period will be documented.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months. The number will be reported at the prescriber level.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

Number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months, who have had a urine drug screen documented within the past 12 months.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

Number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months, who have a Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) documented within the past 12 months. The study team is not administering the screening tool, data will be provided by Wisconsin Collaborative for Healthcare Quality (WCHQ). The PHQ-9 is a 9-question instrument given to patients in a primary care setting to screen for the presence and severity of depression. It is the 9-question depression scale from the Patient Health Questionnaire. Total score can range from 1-27. Interpretation of total scores is as follows: 1-4=Minimal depression, 5-9=Mild depression, 10-14= Moderate depression, 15-19=Moderately severe depression, 20-27= Severe depression.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months, who have documented treatment agreements within the past 12 months.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months and have a daily morphine milligram equivalent over 90 milligrams.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

Number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months, who also have a concurrent benzodiazepine prescription.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of hospital or emergency room visits per patient among patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months, who attend their scheduled clinic visits.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

Population: In this outcome measure, we report the number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months at the clinic level.

The total number of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months. The number will be reported at the clinic level.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 3, clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Clinics will be asked to follow-up with the facilitators via phone or video chat monthly for months 4-6, then quarterly for months 7-18. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing Only
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will attend an educational meeting and receive audit and feedback reports for 18 months. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians will receive academic detailing at month 0 and practice facilitation at month 3. At month 6, clinics will be randomized to receive physician peer consulting. Clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting
n=8 Clinics
Clinicians of this group will attend an educational meeting and will receive a monthly audit and feedback report for 18 months. At month 6, clinicians of the clinics will meet up to 4 times, quarterly, with the physician peer consultant. Systems consultation: Systems consultation consists of three implementation strategies: academic detailing (AD), practice facilitation (PF), and physician peer consulting (PPC). Clinics will receive a combination of these strategies for 18 months. AD: Clinicians will attend an educational meeting that will detail the study and Center for Disease Control guidelines for opioid prescribing in primary care. Clinicians will then will get a monthly audit \& feedback report on their prescribing. PF: clinics will be randomized to receive practice facilitation. Facilitators will travel to each clinics. Facilitators walk through the clinic, identify areas of opioid prescribing workflow improvement, conduct a nominal group technique with the change team, and set a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle. Clinics will follow-up with the facilitators monthly. PPC: Clinicians of the clinics will meet quarterly with the physician peer consultant to discuss tough patient cases and panels regarding opioid prescribing.
Total Number of Patients in a Clinic Who Have Chronic Opioid Prescriptions
985 patients
1175 patients
681 patients
925 patients

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 30 months

The average morphine milligram equivalent of patients who are prescribed at least 3 opioid orders in 3 consecutive months at the clinic level.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

Adverse Events

Academic Detailing Only

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Academic Detailing+Practice Facilitation+Physician Peer Consul

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Academic Detailing+Physician Peer Consulting

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Other adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Additional Information

Dr. Andrew Quanbeck

University of Wisconsin-Madison

Phone: 608-609-7308

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee
  • Publication restrictions are in place