Effectiveness and Cost-effectiveness of Sacral Neuromodulation in Patients With Idiopathic Slow-transit Constipation

Summary

Rationale: Previous reviews showed that the evidence regarding the effectiveness of sacral neuromodulation (SNM) in patients with therapy-resistant, idiopathic (slow-transit) constipation is of suboptimal quality. Furthermore, there is no estimate of costs and cost-effectiveness in this patient group.

Objective: The main objective of this study is to assess the effectiveness of SNM compared to personalized conservative treatment (PCT), in patients with idiopathic slow-transit constipation who are refractory to conservative treatment. The secondary objectives are assessing the 1) costs, 2) cost-effectiveness and 3) budget-impact of SNM compared to PCT.

Hypothesis: Based on previous research we hypothesize that SNM will be more effective than PCT in terms of a significantly higher proportion of patients having treatment success at 6 months.

Study design: An open-label pragmatic randomized controlled trial (RCT) combined with a prospective cohort study.

Study population: Adolescent (14-17 years) and adult (18-80 years) patients with idiopathic slow-transit constipation refractory to conservative treatment.

Intervention: The intervention is SNM, a minimally invasive surgical procedure consisting of two phases. In the screening phase an electrode is inserted near the third sacral nerve and connected to an external stimulator. If the screening phase is successful (average defecation frequency (DF) ≥3 a week), the electrode is connected to a pacemaker that is implanted in the buttocks of the patient. If not successful, patients receive conservative treatment. The control intervention is PCT. This is the best and least invasive alternative to SNM. PCT consists of medication and/or retrograde colonic irrigation.

Main study parameters/endpoints: The primary outcome is success at 6 months, defined as an average DF of ≥3 a week according to a 3-week defecation diary. Secondary outcomes are straining, sense of incomplete evacuation, constipation severity, fatigue, constipation specific and generic (health-related) quality of life ((HR)QOL), and costs at 6 months. Furthermore, cost-effectiveness and budget-impact will be estimated.

Conditions

• Constipation
• Surgery

Interventions

DEVICE

Sacral Neuromodulation

SNM starts with a screening phase. In this phase a tined lead is inserted into the third sacral foramen and attached to an external stimulator, after which the patient enters a four-week stimulation test period. If the screening phase is successful (defecation frequency (DF) ≥3 a week), the external stimulator is changed for a pacemaker that is implanted in the buttocks. If the screening phase is unsuccessful (DF \<3 a week), the lead is explanted. Patients in the intervention group are asked to limit the use of additional conservative treatments for constipation (such as laxatives and colonic irrigation) to what is necessary to relieve (the most severe) complaints. What is necessary to relieve complaints is determined by the patient.

OTHER

Personalized Conservative Treatment

The control group will receive the best and least invasive alternative treatment, which is personalized conservative treatment (PCT). PCT includes, a combination of laxative/medication use and/or colonic irrigation, depending on the preferences of the patient. Use of PCT will be documented.

Sponsors & Collaborators

• Dutch National Health Care Institute

  collaborator OTHER

• Medtronic

  collaborator INDUSTRY

• Maastricht University Medical Center

  lead OTHER

Principal Investigators

• Stéphanie O Breukink, Dr. · Maastricht University Medical Centre+

• Carmen D Dirksen, Prof. dr. · Maastricht University Medical Centre+

Study Design

Allocation

RANDOMIZED

Purpose

TREATMENT

Masking

NONE

Model

PARALLEL

Eligibility

Min Age

14 Years

Max Age

80 Years

Sex

ALL

Healthy Volunteers

No

Timeline & Regulatory

Start

2017-02-21

Primary Completion

2021-07-31

Completion

2021-12-31

Countries

• Netherlands

Study Locations