Trial Outcomes & Findings for Effectiveness of Fluoroscopy-guided MLD for Treatment of BCRL (NCT NCT02609724)
NCT ID: NCT02609724
Last Updated: 2022-03-17
Results Overview
= the ratio at the different time points; The (inter-limb) ratio = Relative excessive lymphoedema volume of the arm/ hand = \[(volume arm + volume hand affected side) / (corrected volume arm + corrected volume hand healthy side)\]; Volume arm is determined by performing circumference measurements and calculating the volume with the formula of the truncated cone; Volume hand is determined by the water displacement method; The volume of the non-dominant hand/arm is on average 3.3% smaller than the dominant hand/arm, therefore is the volume of the arm at the healthy side corrected for hand dominance
COMPLETED
NA
194 participants
Primary endpoint = After 3 weeks of intensive treatment
2022-03-17
Participant Flow
Participant milestones
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Overall Study
STARTED
|
65
|
64
|
65
|
|
Overall Study
Post Intensive Treatment Phase (= Primary Endpoint)
|
63
|
63
|
64
|
|
Overall Study
COMPLETED
|
60
|
61
|
61
|
|
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
|
5
|
3
|
4
|
Reasons for withdrawal
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Overall Study
Death
|
2
|
0
|
1
|
|
Overall Study
Withdrawal by Subject
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
|
Overall Study
Illness
|
2
|
1
|
0
|
Baseline Characteristics
Race and Ethnicity were not collected from any participant.
Baseline characteristics by cohort
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
Total
n=194 Participants
Total of all reporting groups
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Age, Continuous
|
60 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 10.8 • n=65 Participants
|
62 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.5 • n=64 Participants
|
61 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.0 • n=65 Participants
|
61 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.8 • n=194 Participants
|
|
Sex: Female, Male
Female
|
65 Participants
n=65 Participants
|
63 Participants
n=64 Participants
|
65 Participants
n=65 Participants
|
193 Participants
n=194 Participants
|
|
Sex: Female, Male
Male
|
0 Participants
n=65 Participants
|
1 Participants
n=64 Participants
|
0 Participants
n=65 Participants
|
1 Participants
n=194 Participants
|
|
Race and Ethnicity Not Collected
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
0 Participants
Race and Ethnicity were not collected from any participant.
|
|
Region of Enrollment
Belgium
|
65 participants
n=65 Participants
|
64 participants
n=64 Participants
|
65 participants
n=65 Participants
|
194 participants
n=194 Participants
|
|
Body Mass Index
|
27.6 kg/m2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5 • n=65 Participants
|
28.8 kg/m2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5.6 • n=64 Participants
|
27.8 kg/m2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 6.1 • n=65 Participants
|
28.1 kg/m2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5.7 • n=194 Participants
|
PRIMARY outcome
Timeframe: Primary endpoint = After 3 weeks of intensive treatmentPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up.
= the ratio at the different time points; The (inter-limb) ratio = Relative excessive lymphoedema volume of the arm/ hand = \[(volume arm + volume hand affected side) / (corrected volume arm + corrected volume hand healthy side)\]; Volume arm is determined by performing circumference measurements and calculating the volume with the formula of the truncated cone; Volume hand is determined by the water displacement method; The volume of the non-dominant hand/arm is on average 3.3% smaller than the dominant hand/arm, therefore is the volume of the arm at the healthy side corrected for hand dominance
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Lymphoedema Volume at the Level of the Arm/ Hand
Baseline
|
1.228 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.19 to 1.266
|
1.249 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.211 to 1.288
|
1.218 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.181 to 1.256
|
|
Lymphoedema Volume at the Level of the Arm/ Hand
Post intensive treatment phase
|
1.175 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.144 to 1.207
|
1.197 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.165 to 1.229
|
1.164 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.133 to 1.195
|
PRIMARY outcome
Timeframe: Primary endpoint = After 3 weeks of intensive treatmentPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up.
Ratio PWC% at the different time intervals = PWC% affected side / PWC% healthy side Measured with the MoistureMeterD compact at the level of shoulder and trunk where after a mean ratio PWC% is calculated
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Stagnation of Fluid at Level of the Shoulder/ Trunk
Baseline
|
1.045 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.024 to 1.065
|
1.051 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.03 to 1.072
|
1.057 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.036 to 1.078
|
|
Stagnation of Fluid at Level of the Shoulder/ Trunk
Post intensive phase
|
1.088 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.069 to 1.108
|
1.059 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.04 to 1.077
|
1.077 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.058 to 1.096
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment, 1, 3, 6 months of maintenance treatment and 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
L-Dex score, measured with Impedimed BIS device at the different time points Amount of extracellular fluid = represented by L-Dex score This outcome is calculated and displayed on the Impedimed BIS device, and represents the difference in the amount of extracellular fluid in the affected upper limb compared to the unaffected upper limb. Normal L-Dex scores range between -10 and +10. A score outside this range, represents lymphedema. A higher number, represents a worse score.
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Extracellular Fluid in the Upper Limb
3M maintenance
|
20.9 score on a scale
Interval 17.1 to 28.5
|
22.2 score on a scale
Interval 17.8 to 26.5
|
21.1 score on a scale
Interval 16.8 to 25.4
|
|
Extracellular Fluid in the Upper Limb
Baseline
|
33.1 score on a scale
Interval 26.1 to 40.1
|
32.3 score on a scale
Interval 25.3 to 39.3
|
34.9 score on a scale
Interval 28.0 to 41.8
|
|
Extracellular Fluid in the Upper Limb
Post-intensive
|
24.4 score on a scale
Interval 19.1 to 29.6
|
25.4 score on a scale
Interval 20.2 to 30.7
|
23.9 score on a scale
Interval 18.7 to 29.1
|
|
Extracellular Fluid in the Upper Limb
1M maintenance
|
30 score on a scale
Interval 22.2 to 37.8
|
29.5 score on a scale
Interval 21.6 to 37.3
|
25.3 score on a scale
Interval 17.6 to 33.0
|
|
Extracellular Fluid in the Upper Limb
6M maintenance
|
22.8 score on a scale
Interval 17.1 to 28.5
|
22.6 score on a scale
Interval 16.8 to 28.3
|
21.6 score on a scale
Interval 16.0 to 27.3
|
|
Extracellular Fluid in the Upper Limb
6M follow-up
|
28.1 score on a scale
Interval 20.0 to 36.2
|
24.1 score on a scale
Interval 16.0 to 32.3
|
25.4 score on a scale
Interval 17.3 to 33.4
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment and 6 months of maintenance treatment and 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
Analyses for change in thickness of cutis + subcutis were performed: Relative excessive thickness of the cutis+subcutis (inter-limb ratio of cutis+subcutis in mm) = Thickness of cutis+subcutis (mm) affected side / thickness of cutis+subcutis (mm) healthy side Arm: Reference points 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 where after a mean ratio thickness of cutis+subcutis is calculated
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Thickness of Cutis and Subcutis of Arm and Trunk Measured With Ultrasound
Baseline
|
1.52 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.42 to 1.63
|
1.44 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.34 to 1.55
|
1.45 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.35 to 1.56
|
|
Thickness of Cutis and Subcutis of Arm and Trunk Measured With Ultrasound
Post-intensive
|
1.36 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.27 to 1.47
|
1.38 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.3 to 1.47
|
1.36 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.28 to 1.45
|
|
Thickness of Cutis and Subcutis of Arm and Trunk Measured With Ultrasound
6M maintenance
|
1.35 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.27 to 1.44
|
1.40 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.31 to 1.49
|
1.29 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.21 to 1.37
|
|
Thickness of Cutis and Subcutis of Arm and Trunk Measured With Ultrasound
6M follow-up
|
1.31 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.22 to 1.41
|
1.40 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.3 to 1.51
|
1.34 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.24 to 1.44
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment, 1, 3, 6 months of maintenance treatment and 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
Different scores are obtained from the questionnaire. Each of the 29 questions has to be scored on a 11-point Likert scale between 0 and 10 (instead of a VAS between 0 and 100). The total score of the Lymph-ICF-UL is equal to the sum of the scores on the questions divided by the total number of answered questions and multiplied by 10. In addition, a score is determined for each of the five domains of the Lymph-ICFUL: (1) physical function, (2) mental function, (3) household activities, (4) mobility activities, and (5) life and social activities. Thus, the total score on the Lymph-ICF-UL and the score on the five domains range between 0 and 100. The higher the score, the more problems in functioning.
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Problems in Functioning Related to Development of Breast Cancer-related Lymphoedema
Baseline
|
38.0 score on a scale
Interval 32.9 to 43.1
|
35.7 score on a scale
Interval 30.6 to 40.8
|
38.1 score on a scale
Interval 33.0 to 43.1
|
|
Problems in Functioning Related to Development of Breast Cancer-related Lymphoedema
Post-intensive
|
29.0 score on a scale
Interval 24.3 to 33.6
|
27.7 score on a scale
Interval 23.0 to 32.4
|
32.1 score on a scale
Interval 27.5 to 36.7
|
|
Problems in Functioning Related to Development of Breast Cancer-related Lymphoedema
1M maintenance
|
27.8 score on a scale
Interval 23.3 to 32.3
|
24.6 score on a scale
Interval 20.0 to 29.1
|
28.8 score on a scale
Interval 24.3 to 33.3
|
|
Problems in Functioning Related to Development of Breast Cancer-related Lymphoedema
3M maintenance
|
23.3 score on a scale
Interval 18.8 to 27.8
|
25.4 score on a scale
Interval 20.8 to 29.9
|
25.2 score on a scale
Interval 20.7 to 29.8
|
|
Problems in Functioning Related to Development of Breast Cancer-related Lymphoedema
6M maintenance
|
25.3 score on a scale
Interval 20.5 to 30.0
|
24.5 score on a scale
Interval 19.7 to 29.3
|
27.5 score on a scale
Interval 22.8 to 32.3
|
|
Problems in Functioning Related to Development of Breast Cancer-related Lymphoedema
6M follow-up
|
23.2 score on a scale
Interval 18.5 to 27.9
|
24.2 score on a scale
Interval 19.5 to 28.9
|
26 score on a scale
Interval 21.3 to 30.7
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment, 1, 3, 6 months of maintenance treatment and 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
Induration force is presented in Newton (N) by the device. Relative difference in skin elasticity (induration force inter-limb ratio) = Skin elasticity affected side / skin elasticity healthy side Arm: Reference points 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 where after a mean induration ratio is calculated
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Elasticity of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue of Arm and Trunk Using the SkinFibrometer
6M follow-up
|
1.19 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.11 to 1.27
|
1.07 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.01 to 1.14
|
1.15 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.08 to 1.23
|
|
Elasticity of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue of Arm and Trunk Using the SkinFibrometer
Baseline
|
1.28 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.19 to 1.37
|
1.26 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.17 to 1.35
|
1.41 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.31 to 1.51
|
|
Elasticity of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue of Arm and Trunk Using the SkinFibrometer
Post-intensive treatment
|
1.11 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.04 to 1.18
|
1.06 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.0 to 1.13
|
1.14 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.07 to 1.21
|
|
Elasticity of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue of Arm and Trunk Using the SkinFibrometer
1M maintenance
|
1.15 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.08 to 1.23
|
1.07 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.01 to 1.14
|
1.15 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.11 to 1.26
|
|
Elasticity of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue of Arm and Trunk Using the SkinFibrometer
3M maintenance
|
1.16 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.1 to 1.23
|
1.07 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.01 to 1.14
|
1.15 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.08 to 1.22
|
|
Elasticity of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue of Arm and Trunk Using the SkinFibrometer
6M maintenance
|
1.13 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.07 to 1.2
|
1.10 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.04 to 1.17
|
1.14 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.08 to 1.22
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment and 1, 3, 6 months of maintenance treatment and 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
At the end of each assessment, subjects are asked to fill in the questionnaire individually Questionnaire counts 16 + 1 questions, which relate to the following 5 domains: physical symptoms; physical wellbeing, psychological symptoms; existential wellbeing and support A Likert scale with 11 possibilities (0-10) is used for the 16 questions and part D is an open question Each question corresponds to a score between 0 (very bad) and 10 (excellent); a total score and 5 different domain scores are calculated (each between 0 and 10) A lower score indicates a lower Quality of Life
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Quality of Life Score
6M maintenance
|
5.92 score on a scale
Interval 5.43 to 6.41
|
6.02 score on a scale
Interval 5.53 to 6.52
|
6.09 score on a scale
Interval 5.6 to 6.58
|
|
Quality of Life Score
6M follow-up
|
5.96 score on a scale
Interval 5.45 to 6.47
|
5.69 score on a scale
Interval 5.18 to 6.2
|
5.81 score on a scale
Interval 5.3 to 6.32
|
|
Quality of Life Score
Baseline
|
5.96 score on a scale
Interval 5.58 to 6.35
|
6.15 score on a scale
Interval 5.75 to 6.54
|
5.87 score on a scale
Interval 5.48 to 6.26
|
|
Quality of Life Score
Post-intensive
|
6.06 score on a scale
Interval 5.56 to 6.46
|
6.18 score on a scale
Interval 5.77 to 6.59
|
5.82 score on a scale
Interval 5.41 to 6.22
|
|
Quality of Life Score
1M maintenance
|
6.14 score on a scale
Interval 5.71 to 6.58
|
6.21 score on a scale
Interval 5.77 to 6.65
|
5.98 score on a scale
Interval 5.54 to 6.42
|
|
Quality of Life Score
3M maintenance
|
5.85 score on a scale
Interval 5.38 to 6.33
|
6.10 score on a scale
Interval 5.62 to 6.58
|
5.82 score on a scale
Interval 5.35 to 6.3
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: Between baseline and the end of the follow-up phase (12 months)Population: between baseline and the end of the follow-up phase,12 patients were lost-to-follow up in total (or 6%).
At each clinical evaluation, it was asked to the patient if they had had an episode of erysipelas (which is an infection) between today and the previous evaluation. The numbers of episodes were counted, and the causes of this episode of erysipelas were described. The numbers of episodes were compared between the groups.
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Number of Episodes of Erysipelas
|
5 episodes of erysipelas
|
8 episodes of erysipelas
|
7 episodes of erysipelas
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: Between baseline and the end of the follow-up phase (12 months)Population: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
The number patients presented as a percentage that indicated that their complaints have been slightly (3), much (2) or very much improved (1) during 12 months of time
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=60 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=61 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=61 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Overall Treatment Satisfaction
|
80 percentage of participants
|
78 percentage of participants
|
80 percentage of participants
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: Between baseline and the end of the follow-up phase (12 months)Population: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
The mean rating of the perceived effect of the manual lymph drainage (MLD) that patients received during the study (between 0-10). The higher the score, the higher the satisfaction about the effect of the manual lymph drainage received.
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=60 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=61 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=61 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Manual Lymphatic Drainage (MLD)-Specific Treatment Satisfaction
|
8 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 2
|
7 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 2
|
7 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 2
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment phase, after 1, 3, 6 months of maintenance treatments and after 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
Ratio PWC% at the different time intervals = PWC% affected side / PWC% healthy side Measured with the MoistureMeterD compact at different measurement points where after a mean ratio PWC% is calculated Arm: Reference points 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 where after a mean ratio PWC% is calculated
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Local Tissue Water at the Level of the Arm and Trunk
Post-intensive
|
1.372 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.326 to 1.419
|
1.292 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.247 to 1.336
|
1.344 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.3 to 1.391
|
|
Local Tissue Water at the Level of the Arm and Trunk
Baseline
|
1.418 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.365 to 1.473
|
1.354 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.303 to 1.406
|
1.406 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.354 to 1.459
|
|
Local Tissue Water at the Level of the Arm and Trunk
1M maintenance
|
1.383 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.328 to 1.438
|
1.315 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.264 to 1.368
|
1.394 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.34 to 1.449
|
|
Local Tissue Water at the Level of the Arm and Trunk
3M maintenance
|
1.363 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.309 to 1.42
|
1.288 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.236 to 1.342
|
1.358 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.303 to 1.415
|
|
Local Tissue Water at the Level of the Arm and Trunk
6M maintenance
|
1.343 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.29 to 1.399
|
1.298 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.246 to 1.351
|
1.350 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.297 to 1.405
|
|
Local Tissue Water at the Level of the Arm and Trunk
6M follow-up
|
1.343 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.305 to 1.383
|
1.332 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.294 to 1.373
|
1.335 Inter-limb ratio
Interval 1.297 to 1.374
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment, 1, 3, 6 months of maintenance treatment and 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
In total, six reference points (located at the hand (1 reference point) and arm (5 reference points)) are being evaluated and scored (0 or 1) A reference point is scored with 1 in case the skin fold thickness at the affected side is increased compared to the reference point at the non-affected side The final outcome for the arm score is the (cumulated) total score of six reference points 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 (range 0-6), a higher score indicates more presence of thickened skin
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Thickness of the Cutis and Subcutis of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated by Palpation (Pinch Test)
Post-intensive
|
4.62 score on a scale
Interval 4.23 to 5.0
|
4.23 score on a scale
Interval 3.84 to 4.63
|
4.57 score on a scale
Interval 4.18 to 4.96
|
|
Thickness of the Cutis and Subcutis of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated by Palpation (Pinch Test)
3M maintenance
|
4.25 score on a scale
Interval 3.82 to 4.68
|
4.19 score on a scale
Interval 3.76 to 4.62
|
4.22 score on a scale
Interval 3.79 to 4.64
|
|
Thickness of the Cutis and Subcutis of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated by Palpation (Pinch Test)
6M maintenance
|
4.22 score on a scale
Interval 3.77 to 4.67
|
4.03 score on a scale
Interval 3.58 to 4.49
|
4.05 score on a scale
Interval 3.6 to 4.5
|
|
Thickness of the Cutis and Subcutis of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated by Palpation (Pinch Test)
6M follow-up
|
4.09 score on a scale
Interval 3.61 to 4.57
|
3.92 score on a scale
Interval 3.44 to 4.4
|
4.17 score on a scale
Interval 3.69 to 4.65
|
|
Thickness of the Cutis and Subcutis of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated by Palpation (Pinch Test)
Baseline
|
4.43 score on a scale
Interval 4.01 to 4.85
|
4.03 score on a scale
Interval 3.61 to 4.45
|
4.65 score on a scale
Interval 4.23 to 5.07
|
|
Thickness of the Cutis and Subcutis of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated by Palpation (Pinch Test)
1M maintenance
|
4.37 score on a scale
Interval 3.96 to 4.78
|
4.25 score on a scale
Interval 3.84 to 4.66
|
4.22 score on a scale
Interval 3.81 to 4.62
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment, 1, 3, 6 months of maintenance treatment and 6 months of follow-upPopulation: At the post-intensive assessment, 5 patients dropped-out of which 4 patients (2%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the maintenance phase (P6), only 3 additional patients (1.5%) were lost to follow-up. At the end of the follow-up phase (P12), one additional patient was lost to follow-up (12 patients in total since baseline or 6%).
In total, six reference points (located at the hand (1 reference point) and arm (5 reference points)) are being evaluated and scored (0 or 1) A reference point is scored with 1 in case fibrosis of the skin is present The final outcome for the arm score is the (cumulated) total score of six reference points 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 (range 0-6), a higher score indicates more presence of fibrosis
Outcome measures
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=64 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=65 Participants
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Hardness (Fibrosis) of the Skin at the Level of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated Through Palpation
1M maintenance
|
0.37 score on a scale
Interval 0.21 to 0.55
|
0.52 score on a scale
Interval 0.35 to 0.72
|
0.42 score on a scale
Interval 0.26 to 0.61
|
|
Hardness (Fibrosis) of the Skin at the Level of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated Through Palpation
3M maintenance
|
0.17 score on a scale
Interval 0.03 to 0.32
|
0.45 score on a scale
Interval 0.29 to 0.64
|
0.50 score on a scale
Interval 0.33 to 0.69
|
|
Hardness (Fibrosis) of the Skin at the Level of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated Through Palpation
6M maintenance
|
0.15 score on a scale
Interval 0.05 to 0.25
|
0.23 score on a scale
Interval 0.13 to 0.35
|
0.28 score on a scale
Interval 0.17 to 0.4
|
|
Hardness (Fibrosis) of the Skin at the Level of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated Through Palpation
6M follow-up
|
0.22 score on a scale
Interval 0.11 to 0.34
|
0.20 score on a scale
Interval 0.09 to 0.32
|
0.24 score on a scale
Interval 0.13 to 0.37
|
|
Hardness (Fibrosis) of the Skin at the Level of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated Through Palpation
Baseline
|
0.49 score on a scale
Interval 0.32 to 0.67
|
0.26 score on a scale
Interval 0.12 to 0.41
|
0.24 score on a scale
Interval 0.1 to 0.4
|
|
Hardness (Fibrosis) of the Skin at the Level of the Arm and Trunk Evaluated Through Palpation
Post-intensive
|
0.40 score on a scale
Interval 0.22 to 0.59
|
0.44 score on a scale
Interval 0.26 to 0.64
|
0.56 score on a scale
Interval 0.37 to 0.78
|
SECONDARY outcome
Timeframe: After 3 weeks of intensive treatment and 6 months of maintenance treatment1. Total dermal backflow score (0-39). The higher the score, the more dermal backflow is present 2. Amount of efferent lymphatics leaving dermal backflow areas 3. Presence of visible lymph nodes after the break Raw data is currently still being analyzed in order to be able to report on the described outcome measures. At present (March 2022) these analyses are not yet performed. Therefore these results will be reported later on this year (anticipated date: July 2022).
Outcome measures
Outcome data not reported
Adverse Events
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
Traditional MLD
Placebo MLD
Serious adverse events
Adverse event data not reported
Other adverse events
| Measure |
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD
n=63 participants at risk
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and fluoroscopy-guided MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Fluoroscopy-guided MLD: Fluoroscopy-guided MLD is applied on patient-specific lymphatic system (known from lymphofluoroscopy) by applying cleaning techniques on lymph nodes, resorption techniques to stimulate resorption of lymph by lymph capillaries and gliding technique to stimulate transport of lymph through lymph collectors
|
Traditional MLD
n=63 participants at risk
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and traditional MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Traditional MLD: Traditional MLD is applied without knowledge of the patient-specific lymphatic architecture. During MLD no cream or oil is used. A pressure with the hands up to 40 mmHg is applied. Drainage is performed at the level of the jugular and occipital region and the belly (in the depth). Draining techniques are applied on the retroclavicular lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes, humeral lymph nodes and cubital lymph nodes. At the level of the hand, arm, shoulder and trunk, hand movements are applied to stimulate lymphatic transport through the lymph collectors. The therapist's hands perform 'pumping-movements' while stretching the skin.
|
Placebo MLD
n=64 participants at risk
Information, skin care, compression therapy, exercises and placebo MLD 3 weeks (14 sessions of 60 minutes) of intensive treatment 6 months (18 sessions of 60 minutes) of maintenance treatment 6 months of follow-up
Information: During intensive phase: a leaflet with information about the lymphatic system and lymphoedema, clinical evaluation and conservative treatment of lymphoedema During maintenance phase: two informational sessions about self-management and about compression sleeves and other compression material
Skin care: The skin is hydrated during the session. If wounds are present, the wound is cared.
Compression therapy: During intensive phase: application of multi-layer, multi-component bandages During maintenance phase: wearing custom-made compression garment
Placebo MLD: During placebo MLD a superficial massage with massage cream is performed on the patient's contralateral arm and on the belly.
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Blood and lymphatic system disorders
Occurence of erysipelas (not due to the trial, but due to wounds or scratches)
|
7.9%
5/63 • Number of events 5 • Adverse events were collected between baseline and the end of the phollow-up phase (P12), which was one year post-baseline.
see table (results)
|
12.7%
8/63 • Number of events 8 • Adverse events were collected between baseline and the end of the phollow-up phase (P12), which was one year post-baseline.
see table (results)
|
10.9%
7/64 • Number of events 7 • Adverse events were collected between baseline and the end of the phollow-up phase (P12), which was one year post-baseline.
see table (results)
|
Additional Information
Results disclosure agreements
- Principal investigator is a sponsor employee
- Publication restrictions are in place