Trial Outcomes & Findings for Manicaland Cash Transfer Trial for Children in Zimbabwe (NCT NCT00966849)

NCT ID: NCT00966849

Last Updated: 2019-08-02

Results Overview

Recruitment status

COMPLETED

Study phase

NA

Target enrollment

4043 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

1 year

Results posted on

2019-08-02

Participant Flow

The enrolment number (4043) represents the total number of Households enrolled in the study

Unit of analysis: Households

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
Conditional Cash Transfer
Vulnerable households in this arm will receive conditional cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Conditional Cash Transfer: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will only be given the cash if they comply with the following conditions: * An application for a birth certificate must be made for all children under 18 years in the household who do not already have a birth certificate, including all newborn children within 3 months of birth. * All children under 5 years in the household must be up-to-date with vaccinations. * All children under 5 years must attend a growth monitoring clinic twice per year. * All children 6-17 years in the household attended school
Unconditional Cash Transfer
Vulnerable households in this arm will receive unconditional cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Unconditional Cash Transfers: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will not be required to comply with conditions in order to receive the cash. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Control
Vulnerable households in this arm will not receive cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Overall Study
STARTED
3660 1319
3976 1525
3169 1199
Overall Study
COMPLETED
2119 1248
2498 1452
1876 1118
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
1541 71
1478 73
1293 81

Reasons for withdrawal

Withdrawal data not reported

Baseline Characteristics

Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
Conditional Cash Transfer
n=3660 Participants
Conditional Cash Transfer: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will only be given the cash if they comply with the following conditions: * An application for a birth certificate must be made for all children \<18 years in the household who do not already have a birth certificate, including all newborn children within 3 months of birth. * All children \<5 yrs in the household must be up-to-date with vaccinations * All children \<5 yrs must attend a growth monitoring clinic twice per yr * All children 6-17 yrs in the household attended school at least 90% of days in the last month * At least one adult from each household attended at least 2/3 most recent parenting skills classes Other procedures will be the same as in the unconditional cash transfer arm.
Unconditional Cash Transfer
n=3976 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will receive unconditional cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Unconditional Cash Transfers: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will not be required to comply with conditions in order to receive the cash. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Control
n=3169 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will not receive cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Total
n=10805 Participants
Total of all reporting groups
Sex: Female, Male
Female
1179 Participants
n=2397 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.
1332 Participants
n=2661 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.
1064 Participants
n=2135 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.
3575 Participants
n=7193 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.
Age, Categorical
<=18 years
3660 Participants
n=3660 Participants
3976 Participants
n=3976 Participants
3169 Participants
n=3169 Participants
10805 Participants
n=10805 Participants
Age, Categorical
Between 18 and 65 years
0 Participants
n=3660 Participants
0 Participants
n=3976 Participants
0 Participants
n=3169 Participants
0 Participants
n=10805 Participants
Age, Categorical
>=65 years
0 Participants
n=3660 Participants
0 Participants
n=3976 Participants
0 Participants
n=3169 Participants
0 Participants
n=10805 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
1218 Participants
n=2397 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.
1329 Participants
n=2661 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.
1071 Participants
n=2135 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.
3618 Participants
n=7193 Participants • Data on sex are only available for the age-groups to which the primary outcomes and conditions applied - i.e. 0-4 year-olds for birth registration and vaccinations; and 6-17 year-olds for school attendance.

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 year

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Conditional Cash Transfer
n=417 Participants
Conditional Cash Transfer: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will only be given the cash if they comply with the following conditions: * An application for a birth certificate must be made for all children \<18 years in the household who do not already have a birth certificate, including all newborn children within 3 months of birth. * All children \<5 yrs in the household must be up-to-date with vaccinations * All children \<5 yrs must attend a growth monitoring clinic twice per yr * All children 6-17 yrs in the household attended school at least 90% of days in the last month * At least one adult from each household attended at least 2/3 most recent parenting skills classes Other procedures will be the same as in the unconditional cash transfer arm.
Unconditional Cash Transfer
n=528 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will receive unconditional cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Unconditional Cash Transfers: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will not be required to comply with conditions in order to receive the cash. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Control
n=366 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will not receive cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Proportion of Children Under 5 Years in Vulnerable Households That Have a Birth Certificate
252 Participants
255 Participants
163 Participants

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 year

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Conditional Cash Transfer
n=417 Participants
Conditional Cash Transfer: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will only be given the cash if they comply with the following conditions: * An application for a birth certificate must be made for all children \<18 years in the household who do not already have a birth certificate, including all newborn children within 3 months of birth. * All children \<5 yrs in the household must be up-to-date with vaccinations * All children \<5 yrs must attend a growth monitoring clinic twice per yr * All children 6-17 yrs in the household attended school at least 90% of days in the last month * At least one adult from each household attended at least 2/3 most recent parenting skills classes Other procedures will be the same as in the unconditional cash transfer arm.
Unconditional Cash Transfer
n=517 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will receive unconditional cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Unconditional Cash Transfers: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will not be required to comply with conditions in order to receive the cash. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Control
n=360 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will not receive cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Proportion of Children Under 5 Years in Vulnerable Households That Have Up-to-date Vaccinations
317 Participants
393 Participants
253 Participants

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 year

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Conditional Cash Transfer
n=889 Participants
Conditional Cash Transfer: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will only be given the cash if they comply with the following conditions: * An application for a birth certificate must be made for all children \<18 years in the household who do not already have a birth certificate, including all newborn children within 3 months of birth. * All children \<5 yrs in the household must be up-to-date with vaccinations * All children \<5 yrs must attend a growth monitoring clinic twice per yr * All children 6-17 yrs in the household attended school at least 90% of days in the last month * At least one adult from each household attended at least 2/3 most recent parenting skills classes Other procedures will be the same as in the unconditional cash transfer arm.
Unconditional Cash Transfer
n=1046 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will receive unconditional cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Unconditional Cash Transfers: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will not be required to comply with conditions in order to receive the cash. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Control
n=785 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will not receive cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Proportion of Children Aged 6-12 Years That Attended Primary School 80% of Days in the Last Month
772 Participants
895 Participants
608 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 1 year

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Conditional Cash Transfer
n=811 Participants
Conditional Cash Transfer: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will only be given the cash if they comply with the following conditions: * An application for a birth certificate must be made for all children \<18 years in the household who do not already have a birth certificate, including all newborn children within 3 months of birth. * All children \<5 yrs in the household must be up-to-date with vaccinations * All children \<5 yrs must attend a growth monitoring clinic twice per yr * All children 6-17 yrs in the household attended school at least 90% of days in the last month * At least one adult from each household attended at least 2/3 most recent parenting skills classes Other procedures will be the same as in the unconditional cash transfer arm.
Unconditional Cash Transfer
n=922 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will receive unconditional cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Unconditional Cash Transfers: Households will receive bimonthly payments of US$18 plus US$4 per child under 18 years living in the house up to a maximum of 3 children i.e. transfers will vary from $22 to $30. Households will not be required to comply with conditions in order to receive the cash. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Control
n=722 Participants
Vulnerable households in this arm will not receive cash transfers. A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc) will be made available. Parenting skills classes will also be made available. Standard social services will continue in the area. Standard Agricultural Package: A standard agricultural package (e.g. seeds, fertiliser etc.) will be distributed in all study arms including the control arm as a gesture of goodwill to all those participating in the study. Parenting Skills Classes: 2-3 parenting skills classes will be held annually in each study cluster.
Proportion of Children Aged 13-17 Years That Attended Secondary School 80% of Days in the Last Month
735 Participants
812 Participants
570 Participants

Adverse Events

Conditional Cash Transfer

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Unconditional Cash Transfer

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Control

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Other adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Additional Information

Professor Simon Gregson

Imperial College London

Phone: +4402075943279

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee
  • Publication restrictions are in place