Trial Outcomes & Findings for Tiotropium/Salmeterol Inhalation Powder in COPD (NCT NCT00668772)

NCT ID: NCT00668772

Last Updated: 2026-07-16

Results Overview

Change from baseline in trough Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) at the end of the 12-week treatment period is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. It is measured by a spirometer. Trough FEV1 is defined as the pre-dose FEV1 measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment. Trough FEV1 response is defined as the change from baseline: Trough FEV1 response = Trough FEV1 - FEV1 (Baseline)

Recruitment status

TERMINATED

Study phase

PHASE3

Target enrollment

207 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

At baseline and week 12

Results posted on

2026-07-16

Participant Flow

24-week (+ 24 week extension) placebo-controlled (only 1st 12-week period), double-blind, parallel-group, efficacy and safety study in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) patients. Participants randomised to the placebo arm were randomly re-assigned to one of the four active treatments after completing the 12-week period.

All subjects were screened for eligibility prior to participation in the trial. Subjects attended a specialist site which ensured that they (the subjects) strictly met all inclusion and none of the exclusion criteria. Subjects were not to be allocated to a treatment group if any of the entry criteria were violated.

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Overall Study
STARTED
40
41
42
41
43
Overall Study
COMPLETED
0
0
0
0
0
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
40
41
42
41
43

Reasons for withdrawal

Reasons for withdrawal
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Overall Study
Protocol Violation
0
0
0
0
1
Overall Study
Lack of Efficacy
0
0
0
1
1
Overall Study
Adverse Event
0
0
2
0
0
Overall Study
Trial Termination for strategic reasons
40
41
40
40
41

Baseline Characteristics

Tiotropium/Salmeterol Inhalation Powder in COPD

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Total
n=207 Participants
Total of all reporting groups
Age, Continuous
61.9 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 8.0 • n=9 Participants
64.2 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 8.1 • n=27 Participants
63.6 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 7.3 • n=267 Participants
64.4 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 8.6 • n=265 Participants
63.0 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 7.9 • n=568 Participants
63.4 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 7.9 • n=22 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
21 Participants
n=9 Participants
20 Participants
n=27 Participants
23 Participants
n=267 Participants
11 Participants
n=265 Participants
15 Participants
n=568 Participants
90 Participants
n=22 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
19 Participants
n=9 Participants
21 Participants
n=27 Participants
19 Participants
n=267 Participants
30 Participants
n=265 Participants
28 Participants
n=568 Participants
117 Participants
n=22 Participants
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Hispanic or Latino
1 Participants
n=9 Participants
1 Participants
n=27 Participants
1 Participants
n=267 Participants
1 Participants
n=265 Participants
1 Participants
n=568 Participants
5 Participants
n=22 Participants
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Not Hispanic or Latino
39 Participants
n=9 Participants
40 Participants
n=27 Participants
41 Participants
n=267 Participants
40 Participants
n=265 Participants
42 Participants
n=568 Participants
202 Participants
n=22 Participants
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Unknown or Not Reported
0 Participants
n=9 Participants
0 Participants
n=27 Participants
0 Participants
n=267 Participants
0 Participants
n=265 Participants
0 Participants
n=568 Participants
0 Participants
n=22 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
American Indian or Alaska Native
0 Participants
n=9 Participants
0 Participants
n=27 Participants
0 Participants
n=267 Participants
0 Participants
n=265 Participants
0 Participants
n=568 Participants
0 Participants
n=22 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Asian
0 Participants
n=9 Participants
1 Participants
n=27 Participants
0 Participants
n=267 Participants
0 Participants
n=265 Participants
0 Participants
n=568 Participants
1 Participants
n=22 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander
0 Participants
n=9 Participants
0 Participants
n=27 Participants
0 Participants
n=267 Participants
0 Participants
n=265 Participants
0 Participants
n=568 Participants
0 Participants
n=22 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Black or African American
0 Participants
n=9 Participants
3 Participants
n=27 Participants
0 Participants
n=267 Participants
1 Participants
n=265 Participants
0 Participants
n=568 Participants
4 Participants
n=22 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
White
40 Participants
n=9 Participants
37 Participants
n=27 Participants
42 Participants
n=267 Participants
40 Participants
n=265 Participants
43 Participants
n=568 Participants
202 Participants
n=22 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
More than one race
0 Participants
n=9 Participants
0 Participants
n=27 Participants
0 Participants
n=267 Participants
0 Participants
n=265 Participants
0 Participants
n=568 Participants
0 Participants
n=22 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Unknown or Not Reported
0 Participants
n=9 Participants
0 Participants
n=27 Participants
0 Participants
n=267 Participants
0 Participants
n=265 Participants
0 Participants
n=568 Participants
0 Participants
n=22 Participants

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and week 12

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS): The intent-to-treat (ITT) principle was used to include as many participants as possible in the efficacy analyses. The full analysis set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Change from baseline in trough Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) at the end of the 12-week treatment period is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. It is measured by a spirometer. Trough FEV1 is defined as the pre-dose FEV1 measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment. Trough FEV1 response is defined as the change from baseline: Trough FEV1 response = Trough FEV1 - FEV1 (Baseline)

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=6 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=6 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=9 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=11 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Change From Baseline in Trough Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
1.412 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.317
1.480 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.390
1.413 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.408
1.584 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.542
1.031 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.391

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and week 24

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, no endpoint data were collected for week 24.

Change from baseline in trough Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) at the end of the 24-week treatment period is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. Trough FEV1 is defined as the pre-dose FEV1 measured in the clinic at the -10 min time point just prior to inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and at week 12: 10 minutes (min) prior to inhalation, and 30min, 60min, 2hours (hrs), 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS): The intent-to-treat (ITT) principle was used to include as many participants as possible in the efficacy analyses. The full analysis set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) area under the concentration-time curve from 0 to 8 hours (AUC0-8h) response at the end of the 12-week treatment period is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. The FEV1 AUC0-8h is defined as the area under the FEV1 curve (AUC) normalized for time. It was calculated as area under the curve from zero time to 8 h using the trapezoidal rule divided by the corresponding duration (i.e. 8 h) to give the results in litres. The trough FEV1 was assigned to zero time. Trough FEV1 at baseline is defined as the pre-dose FEV1 measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the first morning dose of randomised treatment at the randomisation visit. Response = FEV1 AUC0-8h at week 12 - trough FEV1 at baseline.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=6 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=6 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=9 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=11 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) Area Under the Concentration-time Curve From 0 to 8h (AUC0-8h) Response at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
1.630 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.395
1.526 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.488
1.496 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.472
1.655 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.510
1.239 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.429

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and at week 24: 10 minutes (min) prior to inhalation, and 30min, 60min, 2hours (hrs), 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, no endpoint data were collected for week 24.

Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) area under the concentration-time curve from 0 to 8h (AUC0-8h) response at the end of the 24-week treatment period is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. The FEV1 AUC0-8h is defined as the area under the FEV1 curve (AUC) normalized for time. It was calculated as area under the curve from zero time to 8 h using the trapezoidal rule divided by the corresponding duration (i.e. 8 h) to give the results in litres. The trough FEV1 was assigned to zero time. Trough FEV1 at baseline is defined as the pre-dose FEV1 measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the first morning dose of randomised treatment at the randomisation visit. Response = FEV1 AUC0-8h at week 24 - trough FEV1 at baseline.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of week 12

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS): The intent-to-treat (ITT) principle was used to include as many participants as possible in the efficacy analyses. The full analysis set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

The Mahler Dyspnoea questionnaire is an instrument which measures change from baseline state in the severity of breathlessness (shortness of breath). It is based on the criteria of the various grades for change in functional impairment (any activities started or stopped?), change in magnitude of task (What activities cause breathlessness now?) and change in magnitude of effort (Need to pause while performing activities?), which causes breathlessness, each ranging from grade -3 (major deterioration) to +3 (major improvement). The Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) focal score was calculated as the sum of these three components of the TDI, i.e. change in Functional Impairment, in Magnitude of Task and in Magnitude of Effort. Consequently, TDI ranges from -9 to +9 with a higher score indicating improvement.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=6 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=6 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=8 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=9 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Focal Score at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
0.833 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 1.329
0.667 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 1.211
0.625 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 1.061
1.222 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 1.856
-0.125 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.354

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of week 24

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, no endpoint data were collected for week 24.

The Mahler Dyspnoea questionnaire is an instrument which measures the severity of breathlessness (shortness of breath) change from the baseline state. It is based on the criteria of the various grades for change in functional impairment (any activities started or stopped?), change in magnitude of task (What activities cause breathlessness now?) and change in magnitude of effort (Need to pause while performing activities?), which causes breathlessness, each ranging from grade -3 (major deterioration) to +3 (major improvement). The Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) focal score was calculated as the sum of these three components of the TDI, i.e. change in Functional Impairment, in Magnitude of Task and in Magnitude of Effort. Consequently, TDI ranges from -9 to +9 with a higher score indicating improvement.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of week 24

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, no endpoint data were collected for week 24. The evaluation SGRQ was planned to be based upon pooled data from 48-week sister studies 1184.14 (also prematurely discontinued) and 1184.15.

The St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) is designed as a supervised self-administered questionnaire that determines the impact on overall health, daily life, and perceived well-being in patients with obstructive airways disease. Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating more limitations. The evaluation SGRQ was planned to be based upon pooled data from 48-week sister studies 1184.14 and 1184.15.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 12 weeks

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12. Only patients with COPD exacerbation event were included in the analysis.

Time from start of treatment to first moderate to severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) exacerbation within 48 weeks is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=2 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=1 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=1 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Time to First Moderate to Severe Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) Exacerbation Within 48 Weeks
NA Days
Non-calculable as the median was not reached (and neither was the Q1).
NA Days
Non-calculable as the median was not reached (and neither was the Q1).
NA Days
Non-calculable as the median was not reached (and neither was the Q1).

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 12 weeks.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12.

Number of patients with moderate to severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) exacerbations within 48 weeks is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients With Moderate to Severe Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) Exacerbations Within 48 Weeks
moderate
0 Count of participants
2 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Moderate to Severe Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) Exacerbations Within 48 Weeks
severe
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and at week 4: 10 minutes (min) prior to inhalation, and 30min, 60min, 2hours (hrs), 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 36 and 48.

Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) area under the concentration-time curve from 0 to 8h (AUC0-8h) response after 4, 36 and 48 weeks treatment period is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. The FEV1 AUC0-8h is defined as the area under the FEV1 curve (AUC) normalized for time. It was calculated as area under the curve from zero time to 8 h using the trapezoidal rule divided by the corresponding duration (i.e. 8 h) to give the results in litres. The trough FEV1 was assigned to zero time. Trough FEV1 at baseline is defined as the pre-dose FEV1 measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the first morning dose of randomised treatment at the randomisation visit. Response = FEV1 AUC0-8h at week 4, 36 or 48 - trough FEV1 at baseline.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) Area Under the Concentration-time Curve From 0 to 8h (AUC0-8h) Response After 4, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
1.509 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.459
1.454 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.505
1.370 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.498
1.521 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.485
1.291 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.547

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and week 4.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 36 and 48.

Change from baseline in trough Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) after 4, 36 and 48 weeks treatment period is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. It is measured by a spirometer. Trough FEV1 is defined as the pre-dose FEV1 measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment. Trough FEV1 response is defined as the change from baseline: Trough FEV1 response = Trough FEV1 - FEV1 (Baseline)

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Change From Baseline in Trough Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) After 4, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
1.329 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.433
1.361 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.469
1.308 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.478
1.383 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.444
1.261 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.508

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and at week 4 and 12: within 3h after inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 and 12 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 18, 24, 36 and 48.

FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. Peak FEV1 is defined as the highest FEV1 reading observed within 3 hours after inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment. Peak FEV1 response is defined as the change from baseline: Peak FEV1 response = Peak FEV1 - FEV1 (Baseline)

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Change From Baseline in Peak Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Week 4, 12, 18, 24, 36 and 48
week 4
0.416 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.207
0.274 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.282
0.286 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.234
0.349 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.257
0.116 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.190
Change From Baseline in Peak Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Week 4, 12, 18, 24, 36 and 48
week 12
0.440 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.171
0.335 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.176
0.213 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.231
0.410 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.320
0.268 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.244

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and at week 4 and 12: 10 minutes (min) prior to inhalation, and 30min, 60min, 2hours (hrs), 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 and week 12 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) is the volume of air (measured in milliliter) which can be forcibly exhaled from the lungs after taking the deepest breath possible. The FVC AUC0-8h is defined as the area under the FVC curve (AUC) normalized for time. It was calculated as area under the curve from zero time to 8 h using the trapezoidal rule divided by the corresponding duration (i.e. 8 h) to give the results in litres. The trough FVC was assigned to zero time. Trough FVC at baseline is defined as the pre-dose FVC measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the first morning dose of randomised treatment at the randomisation visit. Response = FVC AUC0-8h at week 4, 12, 24, 36 or 48 - trough FVC at baseline.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
The Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) Area Under the Concentration-time Curve From 0 to 8h (AUC0-8h) Response After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 4
0.533 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.361
0.321 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.359
0.300 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.378
0.351 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.384
0.051 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.324
The Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) Area Under the Concentration-time Curve From 0 to 8h (AUC0-8h) Response After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 12
0.471 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.217
0.384 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.457
0.314 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.525
0.352 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.476
0.229 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.381

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and week 4 and 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 and 12 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) is the volume of air (measured in millilitres) which can be forcibly exhaled from the lungs after taking the deepest breath possible. Trough FVC is defined as the pre-dose FVC measured in the clinic at the -10 minutes time point just prior to inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment. Trough FVC response is defined as the change from baseline: Trough FVC response = Trough FVC - FVC (Baseline)

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Change From Baseline in Trough Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 4
0.236 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.346
0.210 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.321
0.135 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.332
0.214 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.384
-0.006 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.280
Change From Baseline in Trough Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 12
0.203 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.260
0.437 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.403
0.241 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.407
0.328 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.522
-0.115 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.338

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline and at week 4 and 12: within 3 hours after inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 and 12 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 18, 24, 36 and 48.

Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) is the volume of air (measured in millilitres) which can be forcibly exhaled from the lungs after taking the deepest breath possible. Peak FVC is defined as the highest FVC reading observed within 3 hours after inhalation of the morning dose of randomised treatment. Peak FVC response is defined as the change from baseline: Peak FVC response = Peak FVC - FVC (Baseline)

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Change From Baseline in Peak Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Week 4, 12, 18, 24, 36 and 48
week 4
0.826 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.082
0.468 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.383
0.405 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.406
0.495 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.401
0.184 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.364
Change From Baseline in Peak Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Week 4, 12, 18, 24, 36 and 48
week 12
0.582 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.202
0.567 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.459
0.406 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.546
0.460 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.497
0.280 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.311

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4: 10 minutes (min) prior to inhalation, and 30min, 60min, 2hours (hrs), 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period.

Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) at clinic visits at the individual times on week 4 is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. It is measured by a spirometer.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
0 hours
1.329 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.433
1.361 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.469
1.308 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.478
1.383 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.444
1.261 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.508
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
30 minutes
1.469 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.417
1.432 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.492
1.388 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.514
0.449 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.73
1.282 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.550
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
1 hour
1.529 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.445
1.470 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.502
1.388 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.516
1.520 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.471
1.264 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.514
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
2 hours
1.545 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.453
1.466 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.490
1.415 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.536
1.545 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.486
1.294 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.557
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
3 hours
1.560 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.482
1.484 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.492
1.402 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.522
1.532 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.504
1.288 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.573
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
4 hours
1.515 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.463
1.485 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.512
1.384 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.513
1.543 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.499
1.307 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.588
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
6 hours
1.511 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.494
1.443 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.535
1.347 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.485
1.516 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.487
1.300 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.559
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
8 hours
1.462 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.465
1.410 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.542
1.316 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.481
1.518 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.515
1.280 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.553

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 12: 10 minutes (min) prior to inhalation, and 30min, 60min, 2hours (hrs), 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 12 treatment period.

Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) at clinic visits at the individual times on week 12 is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. It is measured by a spirometer.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=6 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=6 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=9 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=11 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
0 hours
1.412 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.317
1.480 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.390
1.413 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.408
1.584 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.542
1.031 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.391
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
30 minutes
1.523 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.325
1.555 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.430
1.456 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.490
1.640 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.522
1.189 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.392
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
1 hour
1.625 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.379
1.583 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.477
1.492 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.498
1.653 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.537
1.201 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.407
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
2 hours
1.647 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.418
1.537 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.457
1.500 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.488
1.711 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.503
1.261 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.462
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
3 hours
1.673 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.419
1.487 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.491
1.498 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.493
1.685 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.492
1.265 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.471
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
4 hours
1.668 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.397
1.547 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.546
1.510 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.475
1.643 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.479
1.249 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.447
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
6 hours
1.643 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.424
1.533 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.482
1.512 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.451
1.645 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.535
1.250 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.436
Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
8 hours
1.600 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.397
1.467 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.527
1.477 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.488
1.635 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.525
1.263 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.439

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4: 10 minutes (min) prior to inhalation, and 30min, 60min, 2hours (hrs), 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period.

Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at clinic visits at the individual times on week 4 is presented. Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) is the volume of air (measured in millilitres) which can be forcibly exhaled from the lungs after taking the deepest breath possible.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
0 hours
2.781 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.867
2.755 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.835
2.752 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.878
2.730 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.732
2.808 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.902
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
30 minutes
3.015 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.847
2.857 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.849
2.842 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.858
2.836 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.809
2.879 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.923
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
1 hour
3.076 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.890
2.884 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.847
2.909 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.892
2.884 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.809
2.830 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.912
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
2 hours
3.080 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.893
2.899 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.807
2.942 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.973
2.913 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.884
2.851 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.941
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
3 hours
3.293 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.597
2.910 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.847
2.925 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.906
2.885 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.809
2.848 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.950
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
4 hours
3.040 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.892
2.885 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.868
2.970 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.941
2.909 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.866
2.864 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.965
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
6 hours
3.083 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.943
2.851 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.893
2.916 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.954
2.827 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.800
2.934 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.137
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
8 hours
3.016 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.891
2.813 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.921
2.890 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.951
2.863 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.839
2.796 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.989

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 12, at 10 min prior and 0 hours (hrs), 30 minutes (min), 1hrs, 2hrs, 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 12 treatment period.

Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at clinic visits at the individual times on week 12 is presented. Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) is the volume of air (measured in millilitres) which can be forcibly exhaled from the lungs after taking the deepest breath possible.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=6 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=6 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=9 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=11 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
4 hours
3.137 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.410
3.083 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.029
3.182 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.106
2.837 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.870
2.563 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.549
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
0 hours
2.843 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.407
3.212 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.970
3.116 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.101
2.836 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.960
2.201 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.518
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
30 minutes
3.013 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.445
3.275 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.983
3.156 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.078
2.831 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.918
2.539 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.465
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
1 hour
3.108 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.368
3.307 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.053
3.208 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.158
2.837 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.901
2.484 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.532
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
2 hours
3.158 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.397
3.213 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.995
3.190 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.170
2.946 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.933
2.548 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.518
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
3 hours
3.192 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.465
3.105 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.050
3.217 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.243
2.891 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.934
2.528 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.528
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
6 hours
3.132 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.406
3.147 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.029
3.198 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.132
2.845 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.937
2.606 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.544
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
8 hours
3.022 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.478
3.118 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.069
3.169 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 1.157
2.846 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.893
2.550 Millilitres (mL)
Standard Deviation 0.522

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4, at 0 hours (hrs), 30 minutes (min), 1hrs, 2hrs, 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period.

Peak expiratory flow (PEF) rate at clinic visits at the individual times on week 4 is presented. Patients received an electronic diary. Peak expiratory flows (PEFs) were determined individually at home and reported by the patient. PEF measurements was performed 10 minutes prior to the first dose of study medication, and at 30, 60 minutes, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8 hours after inhalation of the first dose of randomised treatment. The measurements scheduled at 30 and 60 minutes after inhalation were obtained within ± 5 minutes of the specified time-points. Measurements scheduled at 2-8 hours after inhalation were obtained within ± 10 minutes of the specified time-points. PEF is defined as a person's maximum speed of expiration after a full inspiration.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
0 hours
223.520 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 63.741
243.857 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 90.365
243.560 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 90.006
272.643 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 90.000
222.250 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 98.218
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
30 minutes
241.040 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 66.575
243.393 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 93.803
240.280 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 77.042
284.179 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 87.990
218.714 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 97.828
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
1 hour
252.760 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 68.236
250.857 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 91.497
241.240 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 85.766
286.393 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 92.301
219.571 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 99.639
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
2 hours
251.920 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 69.084
252.571 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 100.919
249.880 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 95.392
290.964 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 93.510
216.643 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 94.516
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
3 hours
254.520 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 70.359
256.964 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 99.745
260.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 96.160
293.929 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 96.211
221.071 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 99.334
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
4 hours
251.160 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 69.149
256.143 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 104.302
269.800 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 106.113
297.393 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 94.811
217.071 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 96.690
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
6 hours
249.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 79.885
251.393 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 110.640
260.560 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 113.115
290.429 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 94.008
221.750 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 93.281
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 4
8 hours
239.560 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 70.413
240.857 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 103.713
254.760 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 97.227
292.750 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 94.539
223.679 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 105.680

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 12, at 0 hours (hrs), 30 minutes (min), 1hrs, 2hrs, 3hrs, 4hrs, 6hrs and 8hrs after inhalation of the morning drug dose.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 12 treatment period.

Peak expiratory flow (PEF) rate at clinic visits at the individual times on week 12 is presented. Patients received an electronic diary. Peak expiratory flows (PEFs) were determined individually at home and reported by the patient. PEF measurements will be performed 10 minutes prior to the first dose of study medication, and at 30, 60 minutes, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8 hours after inhalation of the first dose of randomised treatment. The measurements scheduled at 30 and 60 minutes after inhalation will be obtained within ± 5 minutes of the specified time-points.Measurements scheduled at 2-8 hours after inhalation will be obtained within ± 10 minutes of the specified time-points.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=6 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=6 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=9 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=11 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
0 hours
237.500 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 39.728
253.667 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 106.007
291.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 77.764
304.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 97.313
185.875 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 76.574
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
30 minutes
254.333 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 43.725
252.667 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 93.618
305.667 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 82.192
312.182 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 96.000
202.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 75.510
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
1 hour
280.167 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 54.393
266.500 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 97.044
307.333 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 77.506
319.818 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 107.591
210.750 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 69.899
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
2 hours
283.833 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 66.168
264.500 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 107.727
317.667 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 81.333
332.455 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 104.737
212.625 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 63.200
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
3 hours
278.500 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 68.745
255.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 110.786
313.444 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 84.773
324.455 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 99.993
209.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 62.958
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
4 hours
266.500 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 76.417
255.500 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 111.833
313.889 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 84.817
322.636 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 90.953
209.750 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 67.559
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
6 hours
272.167 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 64.735
256.000 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 106.124
310.778 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 73.608
318.818 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 97.716
205.625 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 62.589
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Rate at Clinic Visits at the Individual Times on Week 12
8 hours
264.833 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 65.371
250.833 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 118.437
307.333 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 82.700
321.818 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 98.841
210.250 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 63.883

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 1 to 14, each morning between 7 a.m. and 10 a.m. (± 30 minutes (min)) at -10 min (± 3 min) prior to the administration of the study medication.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean morning pre-dose peak expiratory flows (PEFs) is presented. Patients received an electronic diary. Peak expiratory flows (PEFs) were determined individually at home and reported by the patient. The pulmonary function test was obtained by spirometry. The best of three efforts was defined as the highest PEF. Patients did not take their morning study medications prior to each morning PEF measurement.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=39 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=40 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 1
215.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 98.32
232.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 100.87
229.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 87.47
259.6 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 94.45
211.1 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 114.55
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 2
212.6 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 97.49
242.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 104.37
227.8 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 84.83
257.4 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 100.49
219.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 115.80
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 3
216.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 97.94
238.6 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 104.25
229.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 86.11
261.2 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 99.50
221.8 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 126.57
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 4
218.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 95.62
234.6 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 112.50
231.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 88.10
266.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 103.27
214.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 129.40
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 5
207.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 81.33
231.5 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 114.35
241.1 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 88.33
264.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 112.68
218.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 127.08
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 6
207.5 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 81.69
222.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 115.46
251.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 92.87
265.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 108.30
221.1 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 128.63
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 7
204.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 83.66
216.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 117.92
257.8 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 93.98
266.5 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 115.48
230.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 136.07
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 8
213.6 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 81.84
231.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 117.81
253.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 89.17
272.2 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 118.29
228.8 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 131.61
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 9
220.5 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 85.59
240.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 126.14
262.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 90.07
266.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 118.35
231.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 139.09
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 10
223.1 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 80.40
245.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 135.18
275.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 101.01
271.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 128.64
233.5 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 155.82
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 11
217.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 76.07
244.9 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 134.19
275.1 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 96.07
258.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 130.27
232.5 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 156.42
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 12
222.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 81.87
251.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 136.56
283.4 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 112.31
290.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 121.57
267.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 199.45
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 13
246.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 64.44
237.5 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 147.01
310.4 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 91.91
309.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 135.63
156.0 Litres (L)/ minute
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 14
239.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 63.56
259.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 178.03
333.7 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 72.87
329.3 Litres (L)/ minute
Standard Deviation 158.37

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 1 to 14, each evening between 7 p.m. and 10 p.m. (± 30 minutes (min)) at -10 min (± 3 min) prior to the administration of the study medication.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean evening pre-dose peak expiratory flows (PEFs) is presented. Patients received an electronic diary. Peak expiratory flows (PEFs) were determined individually at home and reported by the patient. The pulmonary function test was obtained by spirometry. The best of three efforts was defined as the highest PEF. Patients did not take their evening study medications prior to each evening PEF measurement.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=37 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=37 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=39 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 13
266.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 86.58
252.9 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 170.89
314.8 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 102.94
343.4 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 158.86
195.0 Litres (L)/minute
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 2
234.3 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 99.29
261.7 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 108.15
234.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 89.74
267.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 96.59
236.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 108.65
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 1
243.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 95.65
247.1 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 110.27
238.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 93.21
263.3 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 91.95
227.9 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 106.73
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 3
240.4 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 98.25
258.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 114.84
239.9 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 90.65
268.1 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 94.93
230.4 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 111.95
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 4
236.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 92.45
261.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 121.45
243.9 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 92.90
267.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 95.69
228.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 116.41
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 5
223.9 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 85.58
243.3 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 124.78
254.8 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 95.40
263.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 105.12
227.1 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 113.10
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 6
226.2 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 81.82
241.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 124.17
261.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 101.44
275.3 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 112.62
236.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 114.55
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 7
218.2 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 85.68
244.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 118.37
265.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 98.94
276.3 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 121.86
236.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 121.84
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 8
223.7 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 87.94
244.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 119.26
262.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 88.81
278.2 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 120.64
242.9 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 120.95
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 9
241.7 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 91.60
256.4 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 133.32
276.9 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 104.34
270.7 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 117.98
242.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 124.08
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 10
228.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 81.87
264.4 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 141.45
286.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 103.26
278.1 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 133.73
235.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 124.25
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 11
240.4 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 94.41
269.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 143.93
280.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 110.99
257.7 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 121.47
230.8 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 124.38
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 12
237.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 97.87
266.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 142.79
291.0 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 118.85
293.5 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 126.53
261.3 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 159.13
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Peak Expiratory Flows (PEFs)
week 14
264.7 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 85.14
253.2 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 179.93
315.1 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 106.02
316.6 Litres (L)/minute
Standard Deviation 159.16

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4 and 12: 10 minutes prior to the first dose of study medication, and at 30, 60 minutes, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8 hours after inhalation of the first dose of randomised treatment.

Population: FAS consisted of all participants where baseline + any on-treatment efficacy data were available. Definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that number of participants in analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed week 4 and 12 treatment period and no data were collected for week 18, 24, 36, 48. Only patients with available PEF data were included in analysis.

Peak expiratory flow (PEF) are determined by spirometry at clinic visits (week 4, 12, 18, 24, 36 and 48) is presented. Spirometry will begin between 07:00 and 10:00 a.m. PEF measurements will be performed 10 minutes prior to the first dose of study medication, and at 30, 60 minutes, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8 hours after inhalation of the first dose of randomised treatment. The measurements scheduled at 30 and 60 minutes after inhalation will be obtained within ± 5 minutes of the specified time-points.Measurements scheduled at 2-8 hours after inhalation will be obtained within ± 10 minutes of the specified time-points.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Determined by Spirometry at Week 4, 12, 18, 24, 36 and 48
week 4
254.520 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 70.359
256.964 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 99.745
269.800 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 106.113
297.393 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 94.811
223.679 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 105.680
Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) Determined by Spirometry at Week 4, 12, 18, 24, 36 and 48
week 12
283.833 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 66.168
264.500 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 107.727
317.667 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 81.333
332.455 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 104.737
212.625 Litres/minute (L/min)
Standard Deviation 63.200

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 1 to 14, each morning between 7 a.m. and 10 a.m. (± 30 minutes (min)) at -10 min (± 3 min) prior to the administration of the study medication.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean morning pre-dose Forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. FEV1 measurements are performed individually at home and reported by the patient. It is measured by a spirometer. The best of three efforts was defined as the highest FEV1. Patients did not take their morning study medications prior to each morning FEV1 measurement.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=39 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=40 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 14
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.50
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.38
1.6 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.37
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.49
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 1
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.54
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.48
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.39
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
1.1 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.44
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 2
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.50
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.39
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 3
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.53
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.39
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.45
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 4
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.52
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.45
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.39
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.48
1.1 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 5
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.41
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.49
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.39
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.58
1.1 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 6
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.41
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.51
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.38
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.52
1.1 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 7
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.59
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 8
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.38
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.44
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.38
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.57
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 9
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.45
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.67
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 10
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.48
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.69
1.1 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.38
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 11
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.44
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.72
1.1 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.38
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 12
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.55
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.55
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.45
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.53
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
Weekly Mean Morning Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 13
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.51
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.41
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.52
1.0 Litres (L)

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 1 to 14, each evening between 7 p.m. and 10 p.m. (± 30 minutes (min)) at -10 min (± 3 min) prior to the administration of the study medication.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean evening pre-dose Forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) is presented. FEV1 is a measure of lung function and is defined as the maximal amount of air that can be forcefully exhaled in one second. FEV1 measurements are performed individually at home and reported by the patient. It is measured by a spirometer. The best of three efforts was defined as the highest FEV1. Patients did not take their evening study medications prior to each evening FEV1 measurement.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=37 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=37 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=39 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 1
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.49
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.41
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.41
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.51
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 2
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.51
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.52
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 3
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.50
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.45
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.44
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 4
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.51
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.45
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 5
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.45
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.41
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.54
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 6
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.42
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.59
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.49
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 7
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.39
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.69
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.44
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 8
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.40
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.44
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.43
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.60
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.52
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 9
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.44
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.83
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.48
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 10
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.46
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.48
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.49
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.73
1.1 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.35
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 11
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.55
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.49
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.48
1.4 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.79
1.0 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.33
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 12
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.63
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.50
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.48
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.66
1.2 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.33
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 13
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.58
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.47
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.51
1.7 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.60
1.2 Litres (L)
Weekly Mean Evening Pre-dose Forced Expiratory Volume in One Second (FEV1)
week 14
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.56
1.3 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.30
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.50
1.5 Litres (L)
Standard Deviation 0.56

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Weekly up to week 14: per day (24 hours period)

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean number per day of puffs of as-needed salbutamol/albuterol metered dose inhaler (MDI) is presented. Patients inhaled puffs of rescue medication of 100 micrograms (μg) salbutamol/albuterol metered dose inhaler (MDI).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=39 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=40 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 1
1.2 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.11
1.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.87
1.6 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.26
0.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.71
2.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.88
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 2
1.3 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.14
1.8 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.59
1.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.54
1.2 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.18
2.8 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.96
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 3
1.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.77
2.4 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 4.25
1.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.43
1.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.82
2.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.43
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 4
1.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.00
1.7 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.67
1.6 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.31
1.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.09
3.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 4.33
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 5
1.3 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.46
2.2 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.24
1.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.74
1.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.06
2.7 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.86
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 6
1.4 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.70
2.3 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.14
1.4 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.79
1.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.16
2.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.13
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 7
1.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.29
2.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.27
1.3 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.84
1.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.26
2.6 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.21
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 8
1.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.21
3.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 4.32
1.3 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.31
1.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.24
2.6 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.27
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 9
1.2 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.83
3.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 4.27
1.2 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.81
0.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.99
2.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.86
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 10
1.4 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.83
2.4 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.69
1.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.59
0.6 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.41
2.3 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.64
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 11
0.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.46
2.4 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.46
1.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.94
0.3 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 0.74
2.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.64
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 12
0.7 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.06
2.4 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.79
1.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.69
0.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.16
1.5 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 1.98
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 13
1.2 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.15
2.9 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 4.24
1.0 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.12
0.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 0.20
2.0 count of puffs per day
Weekly Mean Number Per Day (24 Hours Period) of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 14
1.2 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 2.17
1.7 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 3.18
0.7 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 0.85
0.1 count of puffs per day
Standard Deviation 0.18

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Weekly up to week 14: at daytime (from morning dose till evening dose of study medication)

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean number at daytime of puffs of as-needed salbutamol/albuterol metered dose inhaler (MDI) is presented. Patients inhaled puffs of rescue medication of 100 micrograms (μg) salbutamol/albuterol metered dose inhaler (MDI).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=39 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=40 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 3
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.99
1.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.57
1.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.14
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.09
2.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.48
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 1
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.16
1.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.93
1.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.87
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.06
2.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.86
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 2
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.29
1.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.04
1.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.15
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.38
2.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.91
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 4
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.01
1.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.79
1.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.97
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.24
2.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 3.06
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 5
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.40
1.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.83
1.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.96
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.22
2.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.20
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 6
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.45
1.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.80
1.0 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.78
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.23
2.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.58
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 7
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.20
1.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.94
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.06
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.42
2.0 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.72
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 8
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.09
1.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.66
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.68
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.37
2.0 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.62
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 9
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.57
1.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.94
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.31
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.35
1.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.17
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 10
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.52
1.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.51
1.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.20
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.91
1.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.06
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 11
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.86
1.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.18
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.58
0.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.67
1.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.27
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 12
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.30
1.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.02
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.32
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.69
1.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.56
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 13
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.39
1.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.45
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.06
0.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.17
1.0 count of puffs
Weekly Mean Number at Daytime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 14
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.33
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.66
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.79
0.0 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.00

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Weekly up to week 14: at nighttime (from evening dose till morning dose of study medication)

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean number at nighttime of puffs of as-needed salbutamol/albuterol metered dose inhaler (MDI) is presented. Patients inhaled puffs of rescue medication of 100 micrograms (μg) salbutamol/albuterol metered dose inhaler (MDI).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=39 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=40 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 1
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.99
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.19
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.64
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.71
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.33
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 2
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.91
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.76
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.70
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.90
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.32
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 3
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.82
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.96
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.59
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.81
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.26
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 4
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.03
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.25
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.69
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.88
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.63
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 5
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.10
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.61
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.00
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.91
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.00
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 6
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.29
1.0 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.67
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.19
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.93
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.14
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 7
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.14
1.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.61
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.88
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.86
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.93
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 9
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.30
1.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.90
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.75
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.67
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.90
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 8
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.14
1.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 2.02
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.86
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.92
0.6 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.99
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 10
0.7 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.35
0.9 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.55
0.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.83
0.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.62
0.5 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.78
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 11
0.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.60
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.53
0.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.68
0.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.12
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.55
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 12
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.77
1.0 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.79
0.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.67
0.2 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.47
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.62
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 13
0.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.82
1.3 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.80
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.11
0.0 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.14
1.0 count of puffs
Weekly Mean Number at Nighttime of Puffs of As-needed Salbutamol/Albuterol Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI)
week 14
0.4 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.80
0.8 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 1.53
0.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.22
0.1 count of puffs
Standard Deviation 0.30

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Per week, up to 14 weeks

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

Weekly mean number of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)-related nighttime awakenings is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=38 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=40 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=40 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 12
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.35
0.3 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 1.01
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.04
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.46
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.33
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 13
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.40
0.6 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 1.47
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.06
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.21
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 10
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.27
0.3 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 1.00
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.13
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.33
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.30
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 3
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.22
0.3 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.60
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.27
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.27
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.35
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 1
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.25
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.43
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.20
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.24
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.36
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 2
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.29
0.4 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.88
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.31
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.37
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.32
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 4
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.36
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.60
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.26
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.40
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.37
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 5
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.24
0.3 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.73
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.23
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.41
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.34
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 6
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.23
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.51
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.28
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.20
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.34
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 7
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.21
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.60
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.15
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.34
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.36
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 8
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.26
0.3 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.84
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.28
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.14
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.33
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 9
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.24
0.3 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.87
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.28
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.34
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.31
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 11
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.31
0.3 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 1.03
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.16
0.1 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.24
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.55
Weekly Mean Number of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)-Related Nighttime Awakenings
week 14
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.41
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.00
0.0 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.00
0.2 count of awakenings per nighttime
Standard Deviation 0.45

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 14.

The Mahler Dyspnoea questionnaire is an instrument which measures change from baseline state in the severity of breathlessness (shortness of breath). It is based on the criteria of the various grades for change in functional impairment (any activities started or stopped?), change in magnitude of task (What activities cause breathlessness now?) and change in magnitude of effort (Need to pause while performing activities?), which causes breathlessness, each ranging from grade -3 (major deterioration) to +3 (major improvement). The Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) focal score was calculated as the sum of these three components of the TDI, i.e. change in Functional Impairment, in Magnitude of Task and in Magnitude of Effort. Consequently, TDI ranges from -9 to +9 with a higher score indicating improvement.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Focal Score Collected After 4, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
1.720 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 2.170
0.571 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 1.894
1.120 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 2.682
1.429 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 2.116
-0.321 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 1.307

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of week 4 and 12.

Population: Full analysis set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

The Mahler Dyspnoea questionnaire is an instrument which measures change from baseline state in the severity of breathlessness (shortness of breath). It is based on the criteria of the various grades for change in functional impairment (any activities started or stopped?), change in magnitude of task (What activities cause breathlessness now?) and change in magnitude of effort (Need to pause while performing activities?), which causes breathlessness, each ranging from grade -3 (major deterioration) to +3 (major improvement).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Domain Score - Functional Impairment Collected After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 4
0.480 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.918
0.179 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.612
0.360 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.907
0.357 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.911
-0.071 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.539
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Domain Score - Functional Impairment Collected After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 12
0.500 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.837
0.167 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.408
0.125 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.354
0.111 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.928
0.000 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.000

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of week 4 and 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

The Mahler Dyspnoea questionnaire is an instrument which measures the severity of breathlessness (shortness of breath) change from the baseline state. The Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) domain score - magnitude of task is based on the criteria of change in magnitude of task (What activities cause breathlessness now?) which causes breathlessness, ranging from grade -3 (major deterioration) to +3 (major improvement).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Domain Score - Magnitude of Task Collected After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 4
0.640 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.757
0.286 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.659
0.400 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.816
0.536 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.744
-0.071 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.378
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Domain Score - Magnitude of Task Collected After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 12
0.167 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.408
0.333 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.516
0.125 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.354
0.444 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.527
0.000 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.000

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of week 4 and 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

The Mahler Dyspnoea questionnaire is an instrument which measures the severity of breathlessness (shortness of breath) change from the baseline state. The Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) domain score - magnitude of effort is based on the criteria of change in magnitude of effort (Need to pause while performing activities?) which causes breathlessness, ranging from grade -3 (major deterioration) to +3 (major improvement).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=25 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=28 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=25 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=28 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=28 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Domain Score - Magnitude of Effort Collected After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 4
0.600 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.764
0.107 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.737
0.360 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.995
0.536 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.793
-0.179 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.476
Mahler Transition Dyspnoea Index (TDI) Domain Score - Magnitude of Effort Collected After 4, 12, 24, 36 and 48 Weeks Treatment Period
week 12
0.167 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.408
0.167 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.408
0.375 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.518
0.667 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.866
-0.125 score on a scale
Standard Deviation 0.354

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4 and 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

The St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) is designed as a supervised self-administered questionnaire that determines the impact on overall health, daily life, and perceived well-being in patients with obstructive airways disease. Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating more limitations.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=42 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Total Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 4
38.990 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 19.286
42.235 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 15.642
39.706 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.172
39.563 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.108
41.524 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 16.683
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Total Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 12
39.078 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 19.155
42.034 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 15.611
39.410 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.531
38.362 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.080
41.530 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 16.972

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4 and 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

The St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) is designed as a supervised self-administered questionnaire that determines the impact on overall health, daily life, and perceived well-being in patients with obstructive airways disease. The impact domain score is a part of the SGRQ that measures the impact of disease on daily life. Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating more limitations.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=42 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Impact Domain Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 4
28.646 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 20.410
29.754 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 14.855
29.725 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.896
28.490 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.325
30.200 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 16.465
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Impact Domain Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 12
28.387 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 20.315
29.587 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 15.069
29.563 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.993
27.208 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 17.040
30.159 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 16.914

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4 and 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

The St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) is designed as a supervised self-administered questionnaire that determines the impact on overall health, daily life, and perceived well-being in patients with obstructive airways disease. The activity domain score is a part of the SGRQ that measures the activity of the patient. Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating more limitations.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=42 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Activity Domain Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 4
54.576 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 21.390
59.278 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 20.856
55.290 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 22.057
56.383 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 18.650
57.001 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 22.815
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Activity Domain Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 12
54.735 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 21.228
59.076 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 21.047
55.174 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 22.169
54.437 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 19.560
56.429 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 23.492

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At week 4 and 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48.

The St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) is designed as a supervised self-administered questionnaire that determines the impact on overall health, daily life, and perceived well-being in patients with obstructive airways disease. The symptoms domain score is a part of the SGRQ that measures the symptoms of the patient. Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating more limitations.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=42 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Symptoms Domain Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 4
43.421 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 25.216
50.816 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 23.597
42.992 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 23.198
44.125 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 24.425
49.287 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 21.253
St George Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ) Symptoms Domain Score Collected at 4, 12, 36 and 48 Weeks
week 12
44.486 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 25.275
50.667 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 22.629
41.794 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 23.982
44.434 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 23.781
50.445 Score on a scale
Standard Deviation 21.763

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: From randomisation till end of treatment, up to 12 weeks.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12. Placebo patients were excluded from this analysis.

Number of patients with adverse events within the 48-week treatment period is presented. A patient may be counted in more than one seriousness criterion.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
serious AE (disability)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
serious AE (other)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
any adverse event (AE)
12 Count of participants
14 Count of participants
13 Count of participants
13 Count of participants
12 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
severe AE
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
investigator-defined drug-related AE
1 Count of participants
2 Count of participants
3 Count of participants
3 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
other significant AE (according to ICH-E3)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
AE leading to discontinuation of trial drug
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
significant AE (pre-specified events)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
serious AE (fatal)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
serious AE (life-threatening)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
serious AE (required hospitalisation)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
serious AE (prolonged hospitalisation)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Adverse Events Within the 48-week Treatment Period
serious AE (congenital anomaly)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline, week 4 and week 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12.

Number of patients with marked changes in vital signs (decrease) by clinic visit is presented. Vital signs: pulse rate and blood pressure (BP) (after five minutes rest in seated position) recorded pre-dose on each pulmonary function test day and in conjunction with spirometry for the first 3 hours post-dosing. Systolic BP Decrease: Below 100 mmHg if not at that level at baseline and a decrease of greater than 10 mmHg below baseline. Diastolic BP Decrease: Below 60 mmHg if not at that level at baseline and a decrease of greater than 10 mmHg below baseline. Pulse rate Decrease: Below 60 bpm if not at that level at baseline and a decrease of greater than 10 bpm below baseline.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Decrease) by Clinic Visit
systolic BP (week 4)
3 Count of participants
3 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
3 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Decrease) by Clinic Visit
systolic BP (week12)
1 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Decrease) by Clinic Visit
diastolic BP (week 4)
2 Count of participants
2 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Decrease) by Clinic Visit
diastolic BP (week 12)
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Decrease) by Clinic Visit
pulse rate (week 4)
2 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Decrease) by Clinic Visit
pulse rate (week 12)
1 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At baseline, week 4 and week 12.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12.

Number of patients with marked changes in vital signs (increase) by clinic visit is presented. Vital signs: pulse rate and blood pressure 8BP) (after five minutes rest in seated position) recorded pre-dose on each pulmonary function test-day and in conjunction with spirometry for the first 3 hours post-dosing. Systolic BP Increase : An increase of 25 mmHg or more above baseline. Diastolic BP Increase: Above 90 mmHg and an increase of greater than 10 mmHg above baseline. Pulse rate Increase : Greater than 100 bpm if not at that level at baseline and an increase greater than 10 % above baseline.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Increase) by Clinic Visit
systolic BP (week 4)
3 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
2 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Increase) by Clinic Visit
systolic BP (week 12)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Increase) by Clinic Visit
diastolic BP (week 4)
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
2 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Increase) by Clinic Visit
diastolic BP (week 12)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Increase) by Clinic Visit
pulse rate (week 4)
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
1 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
Number of Patients With Marked Changes in Vital Signs (Increase) by Clinic Visit
pulse rate (week 12)
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants
0 Count of participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of the 12-week treatment period.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, not all Full Analysis Set (FAS) participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48. FAS consists of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data are available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Number of patients with abnormal haematology at the end of the 12-week treatment period is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=5 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=5 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=8 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=10 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Basophils higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Eosinophils lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Eosinophils higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute eosinophils lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute eosinophils higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Haematocrit lower
1 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Haematocrit higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Haemoglobin lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Haemoglobin higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute lymphocyte lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute lymphocyte higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Lymphocytes lower
1 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Lymphocytes higher
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute monocytes lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute monocytes higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Monocytes lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Monocytes higher
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute neutrophils lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute neutrophils higher
1 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Neutrophils lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Neutrophils higher
1 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Platelets lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Platelets higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Red blood cell morphology (qualitative) lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Red blood cell morphology (qualitative) higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Red blood cell count lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Red blood cell count higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
White blood cell morphology (qualitative) lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
White blood cell morphology (qualitative) higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute basophils higher
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Basophils lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Absolute basophils lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
White blood cell count lower
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Haematology at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
White blood cell count higher
1 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of the 12-week treatment period.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, not all Full Analysis Set (FAS) participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48. FAS consists of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data are available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Number of patients with abnormal blood chemistry at the end of the 12-week treatment period is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=5 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=5 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=8 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=10 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Alkaline phosphatase decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Total bilirubin increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Total bilirubin decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Blood urea nitrogen increase
1 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Blood urea nitrogen decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Calcium increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Calcium decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Creatinine increase
2 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Creatinine decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Gamma glutamyltransferase increase
2 Participants
1 Participants
2 Participants
3 Participants
1 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Gamma glutamyltransferase decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Alanine aminotransferase increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Alanine amoínotransferase decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Aspartate aminotransferase increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Aspartate aminotransferase decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Albumin increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Albumin decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Alkaline phosphatase increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Phosphate decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Potassium increase
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Potassium decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Total protein increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Total protein decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Sodium increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Sodium decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Uric acid increase
1 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Uric acid decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Glucose increase
3 Participants
1 Participants
1 Participants
2 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Glucose decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Lactate dehydrogenase increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Lactate dehydrogenase decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Blood Chemistry at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Phosphate increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: At the end of the 12-week treatment period.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, not all Full Analysis Set (FAS) participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48. FAS consists of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data are available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Number of patients with abnormal urinalysis at the end of the 12-week treatment period is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=6 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=5 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=8 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=10 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=8 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine blood (qualitative) increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine blood (qualitative) decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine glucose (qualitative) increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine glucose (qualitative) decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine pH increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine pH decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine protein (qualitative) increase
2 Participants
3 Participants
2 Participants
4 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine protein (qualitative) decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine specific gravity increase
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
Number of Patients With Abnormal Urinalysis at the End of the 12-week Treatment Period
Urine specific gravity decrease
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants
0 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 48 weeks.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, no endpoint data were collected for this endpoint.

Vital status of randomised patients is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 12 weeks.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, not all Full Analysis Set (FAS) participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12. FAS consists of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data are available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Number of days in hospital within the 48-week treatment period is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Days in Hospital Within the 48-week Treatment Period
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 12 weeks.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12.

Number of unscheduled health care provider visits within the 48-week treatment period is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Unscheduled Health Care Provider Visits Within the 48-week Treatment Period
0.13 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.40
0.17 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.44
0.24 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.48
0.27 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.87
0.12 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.39

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 12 weeks.

Population: Full Analysis Set (FAS) consisted of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data were available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints. As study was discontinued prematurely, not all FAS participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12.

Number of emergency room visits within the 48-week treatment period is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Emergency Room Visits Within the 48-week Treatment Period
0.00 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.00
0.00 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.00
0.02 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.15
0.00 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.00
0.00 count of visits
Standard Deviation 0.00

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 12 weeks.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, not all Full Analysis Set (FAS) participants completed the weekly treatment periods and no endpoint data were collected later than week 12. FAS consists of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data are available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Number of days in intensive care unit within the 48-week treatment period is presented.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Days in Intensive Care Unit Within the 48-week Treatment Period
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0
0.0 days
Standard Deviation 0.0

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Up to 12 weeks.

Population: As study was discontinued prematurely, not all Full Analysis Set (FAS) participants completed the week 4 treatment period and no endpoint data were collected for week 24, 36 and 48. FAS consists of all participants where baseline data and any on-treatment efficacy data are available. This definition was applied separately for each endpoint, so that the number of participants in the analysis may vary across endpoints.

Number of patients receiving concomitant medication is presented. Concomitant medication was observed for rerandomized placebo patients during placebo treatment and on-treatment periods.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=40 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=41 Participants
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=42 Participants
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=41 Participants
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 Participants
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Number of Patients Receiving Concomitant Medication
37 Count of participants
38 Count of participants
40 Count of participants
37 Count of participants
36 Count of participants

Adverse Events

FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)

Serious events: 1 serious events
Other events: 3 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 7 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Salmeterol (Salm25PE)

Serious events: 1 serious events
Other events: 5 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 6 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Placebo

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 3 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Serious adverse events
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=41 participants at risk
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=43 participants at risk
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=45 participants at risk
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=43 participants at risk
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 participants at risk
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Blood and lymphatic system disorders
Anaemia
2.4%
1/41 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/45 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
Infections and infestations
Pulmonary tuberculosis
0.00%
0/41 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
2.2%
1/45 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Haemoptysis
0.00%
0/41 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
2.2%
1/45 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
0.00%
0/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.

Other adverse events

Other adverse events
Measure
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol (T+S_PE)
n=41 participants at risk
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms of salmeterol were administered orally once daily in the morning from blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey Handihaler device and once daily in the evening from the blue Handihaler device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Tiotropium (Tio18GEL)
n=43 participants at risk
One dose gelatine capsule of inhalation powder containing 18 micrograms tiotropium was administered orally once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Salmeterol (Salm25PE)
n=45 participants at risk
One dose polyethylene (PE) capsule of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally twice daily in the morning and evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
FDC Tiotropium / Salmeterol + Salmeterol (T+S_PE / S25PE)
n=43 participants at risk
One fixed dose combination (FDC) capsule of inhalation powder containing 7.5 micrograms tiotropium and 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered orally once daily in the morning from the blue HandiHaler® device and one dose of inhalation powder containing 25 micrograms salmeterol was administered once daily in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 24 weeks (+24 week extension). One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered once daily in the morning from the grey HandiHaler® device. The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Placebo
n=43 participants at risk
One capsule of inhalation powder of placebo was administered daily in the morning from the blue and grey HandiHaler® device and in the evening from the blue HandiHaler® device for treatment duration of 12 weeks (Patients randomized into the placebo group were re-assigned at random to one of the four active treatments (T+S\_PE, Tio18GEL, Salm25PE, T+S\_PE/S25PE) for the remaining 36 weeks of the 48-week study period.). The morning and evening dose of study medication had to be taken at approximately the same time, the evening dose had to be taken approximately 12 hours after the morning dose. All medications were self-administered by patients.
Infections and infestations
Nasopharyngitis
4.9%
2/41 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
4.7%
2/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
6.7%
3/45 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
7.0%
3/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
4.7%
2/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
2.4%
1/41 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
14.0%
6/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
6.7%
3/45 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
7.0%
3/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.
2.3%
1/43 • From first dose of study drug until end of week 12
The treated set (TS): The treated set consists of all randomised patients who took at least one dose of study medication. Due to re-randomisation of some placebo patients, patients in the different treatment arms are not mutually exclusive.

Additional Information

Boehringer Ingelheim, Call Center

Boehringer Ingelheim

Phone: 1-800-243-0127

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee Boehringer Ingelheim (BI) acknowledges that investigators have the right to publish the study results. Investigators shall provide BI with a copy of any publication or presentation for review prior to any submission. Such review will be done with regard to proprietary information, information related to patentable inventions, medical, scientific, and statistical accuracy within 60 days. BI may request a delay of the publication in order to protect BI's intellectual property rights.
  • Publication restrictions are in place

Restriction type: OTHER